220 likes | 337 Views
European Carbon Sinks Modeling Status, Data, Analytical Gaps, EUFASOM. Uwe A. Schneider Research Unit Sustainability and Global Change Hamburg University. Sink Modeling Status. EU Commission 2002: Potential of European sinks from both agriculture and forestry unclear
E N D
European Carbon SinksModeling Status, Data, Analytical Gaps, EUFASOM Uwe A. Schneider Research Unit Sustainability and Global Change Hamburg University
Sink Modeling Status • EU Commission 2002: Potential of European sinks from both agriculture and forestry unclear • Fast analysis needed for • International negotiation of Kyoto Protocol (define own position and understand others) • EU emission trading system
EU Emission Trading - Sinks • No initial allowance to use credits from carbon sinks projects such as forestry to meet emission targets • Review of the emissions trading directive in 2006: if reporting and accounting uncertainties surrounding sinks can be lifted, it leaves open the possibility of using the credits from 2008.
Integrated Sink Enhancement Assessment (INSEA) Project • Funded by European Commission to address analytical gap of carbon sinks in European Agricultural and Forestry • January 2004 – July 2006
Common Data • Soil • Forests • Climate • Technologies • Markets • Model Results Geographical Analysis • Biophysical Models • EPIC • PICUS • Economic Models • Hohenheim • AROPAJ • EFI • EU-FASOM • AGRIPOL INSEA Model Structure
Available Data • Soils (MOSES, JRC) • Climate (MARS) • Forest Inventories (EFI) • Conventional Management (FADN, EUROCARE, EUROSTAT, IIASA) Problems: Confidentiality restrictions, Data quality, Property rights
Soil DataSource: Luca Montanarella, Joint Research Center, Ispra, Italy
Analytical and Data Gaps • Farm level impacts of alternative agricultural and forest management • Costs • Inputs • Outputs • Environmental Impacts
Addressing the Gaps • Engineering Analysis • Link to other (European) projects • GREENGRASS - Sources and Sinks of Greenhouse Gases from managed European Grasslands and Mitigation Strategies • CARBOINVENT - Multi-Source Inventory Methods For Quantifying Carbon Stocks And Stock Changes In European Forests • MIDAIR - Greenhouse Gas Mitigation for Organic and Conventional Dairy Production • CARBO-AGE - Age-related dynamics of carbon exchange in European forests
European Non-Food Agriculture (ENFA) Project • Starting in 2005 • Includes detailed biofuel analysis • Environmental impact analysis consistent with food options • Integration in EUFASOM • Analysis of fuel directives
Benefits for North American Sink Analysis • Refinement of European Data in global models • Parallel links, i.e. USFASOM and EUFASOM • Extrapolation of European Strategies currently not modeled in US
European Forest and Agricultural Sector Model (EU-FASOM) • Model built from scratch • Uses conceptual approach of (US)-FASOM • Mathematical programming based optimization model • Partial equilibrium
EU-FASOM - Deviations from USFASOM • Texture based land quality classifications • Rotations vs. individual crops • Dynamic soil carbon rates • Validation
Dynamic Soil Carbon Coefficients • Soil-climate-regime andsoilmanagement history determines soil carbon coefficients • Various strategies can be a source or sink depending on the carbon level of the associated land unit
Problem of Dimensionality • Consider a forward looking decision model with 20 alternative soil management practices and 30 time periods • The number of possible management sequences equals 2030 ~ 1E+39 • Many models yield more combinations (regions, crops, …)
Technical Implementation • Details available in paper available from author • X = land use variable • S = Soil carbon variable • t = time index • r = region index • i = soil type index • u = land use index • o = soil carbon class index • s = sequestration coefficient • c = carbon content coefficient • = soil carbon class transistion probability
Soil Carbon Class Distribution Calculation of probabilities is not shown but available in the paper Soil Carbon Levels
Soil Carbon Change a) b)