Understanding the Bilingual Education Controversy

1. Understanding the Bilingual Education Controversy Let us remember: Goals of Bilingual Education: Subject matter knowledge, i.e., the development of academic skills; Biliteracy, i.e., the development of literacy both in English and in the heritage language.

2. Understanding the Bilingual Education Controversy Good bilingual programs: Provide background knowledge through the first language via subject matter teaching in the first language to the point that subsequent subject matter instruction in English is comprehensible; Provide literacy in the first language; Provide comprehensible input in English, through ESL and sheltered instruction.

3. Understanding the Bilingual Education Controversy Main points of the controversy: Definition of bilingual education; Types of programs appropriate for language minority students; Role of public schools in promoting bilingualism; How to measure academic achievement among language minorities.

4. Main points of the controversy: Issue of segregation; Preservation of native language and cultures; National unity and democratic values and equal education opportunities; Role of home in preserving heritage languages; Political and economic advantages of English v. multiculturalism; Linguistics and cognitive advantages; Cultural and social advantages; Types of research and validity.

5. Circumstantial arguments against bilingual educaiton

6. 1. The United States is a monolingual nation where English is considered the main and only language of the country. However, English is loosing ground to other languages now spoken in the United States • Counterevidence: • In spite of massive immigration, the English has survived without any help from the government, such an official-language legislation.

7. Counterevidence: • To the contrary of the opponent’s views, today’s immigrants appear to be acquiring English more rapidly than ever before. 2. Newcomers to the United States are learning English more slowly than in previous generations States

8. 3. Bilingualism disrupts the unity of the country. Language unity helps us build a national character and identity in the midst of so many diverse elements, including ethnic, cultural and linguistic diversity. • Counterevidence: • Bilingualism is a natural gift in a diverse country such as ours.

9. Counterevidence: • US residents recognize the importance of English. However, multilingualism is a tremendous resource to the country’s global competitiveness. 4. English has historically been the language of opportunities. By learning English, immigrants and following generations will be empowered.

10. Counterevidence: • The climate of full cognitive development is crucial in the development of L2. Input must be comprehensible to promote L2 acquisition. There is no credible evidence to support the claim that the more children are exposed to English, the more English they will learn. 5. The best way to learn a language is through “total immersion”. The more contact with the language the faster one learns it .

11. Counterevidence: • Truly bilingual programs seek to cultivate proficiency in both languages, and research has shown that students’ native language can be maintained and developed at no cost to English learn. 6. Children learning English are retained too long in bilingual classrooms, at the expense of English acquisition it.

12. Counterevidence: • The climate of full cognitive development is crucial in the development of a second language. Indeed the best age to acquire an L2 is 9-21. 7. The earlier in life one learns a language the better.

13. Counterevidence: • All programs serving ELL’s cost little more than regular programs for native speakers. Federal law and court cases require special languages services for language minorities. 8. Bilingual instruction is far more costly than English language instruction.

14. Counterevidence: • Latino school dropout is the result a series of background variables: poverty, racism, shortage of successfully schooled Latino role models, under-empowering school culture: lack of material resources and reading material, lack of qualified bilingual teachers, and administrative support. 9. Disproportionate dropout rates for Hispanic students demonstrate the failure of bilingual education.

15. Counterevidence: • Contrary to what is shown by the opinion polls on bilingual education the public is not against bilingual education. The results of English-only acceptance are due to a bias posed by the poll questions. 10. Public is against bilingual education. In particular language-minority parents do not support bilingual education .

16. Counterevidence: • Research on linguistic and learning issues is advancing demonstrating the linguistic and cognitive advantages of bilingual education, resulting on personal and social advancement. 11. Many have been successful without bilingual programs.

17. Further implications The public needs to be educated; School districts must have coherent guidelines, and personnel must believe in the program model they are expected to implement; The country needs to prepare good bilingual teachers;

18. Further implications Well-trained and certified teachers in well-structured and well-supported programs are the best qualified to deal with students with a wide range of language proficiency and academic performance levels; The debate must be placed not on battling research finding and competing models of instruction, but on finding ways of better serving language minorities;