210 likes | 433 Views
LG Electronics Inc. LGEHQ CAC Team. Toshiba S-MMS vs LG MULTI V Plus II. 1. Compressor comparison. Inverter Scroll compressor is the best solution for a commercial building. 2. Power consumption comparison. ■ Design condition of HCL COMNET SYSTEMS & SERVICES LTD
E N D
LG Electronics Inc. LGEHQ CAC Team Toshiba S-MMS vs LG MULTI V Plus II
1. Compressor comparison Inverter Scroll compressor is the best solution for a commercial building.
2. Power consumption comparison ■ Design condition of HCL COMNET SYSTEMS & SERVICES LTD - Total capacity of system : 560Hp (48Hp * 11EA / 32Hp * 1EA) ■ Operation condition of A/C units - 24hours / day, 30days / month, 12month / year - Electrical charge : 6Rs / kWh
3. Performance comparison under the hot temp. Inverter Scroll compressor has high performance under the condition of hot temp. 135 52.55 130.37 49.67 45.38 125.60 42.00 <Cooling Capacity> <Power consumption>
4. Compressor comparison (Efficiency) Rotary compressor is weak for liquid compressing and has 92% cooling and heating efficiency compared to scroll compressor. Capacity (kW) Toshiba S-MMS MULTI V PLUS II 24.0 MULTI V PLUS II 25 Rotary type Scroll type Type 20 19.4 16.3 ※Based on 1 inverter comp. 15 Structure 13.1 Frequency (Hz) 60 90 120 ※Reference from each companies’ compressor catalogue MULTI V PLUS II Less Liquid handling Convenient for handling large capacity Feature Volumetric Efficiency 92% 100% (Base) [Efficiency comparison for compressor type (reference from air-conditioning technology thesis)] Origin of Development Toshiba (Japan) LG (Korea)
5. Design limit comparison LG MULTI V PLUS II is excellent for maximum pipe length ■ LG MULTI V PLUS II system has a plate type sub-cooling HEX • Increased sub-cooling by plate-type heat exchanger • Enable to be long piping length and level difference • More powerful Cooling operation Plate typeSC
103m Appendix. Design limit of MULTI V PLUS II Outdoor units MULTI V Plus II 110m ON ON ON Indoor units <DA Research Lab in Korea>
Appendix. Power consumption of Toshiba S-MMS ■ Power consumption of Toshiba S-MMS48HP : 49.67kW/h ※ Source - Toshiba Engineering data book
Appendix. Power consumption of Toshiba S-MMS ■ Power consumption of Toshiba S-MMS32HP : 28.65kW/h ※ Source - Toshiba Engineering data book
Appendix. Power consumption of MULTI V PLUS II ■ Power consumption of MULTI V PLUS II 48HP : 42kW/h
Appendix. Power consumption of MULTI V PLUS II ■ Power consumption of MULTI V PLUS II 32HP : 28kW/h
Appendix. Compressor capacity of Toshiba ■ No of compressors – Toshiba S-MMS 48HP : 8 Compressors (4.2kW*2)*4 ※ Source - Toshiba Engineering data book
Appendix. Compressor capacity of LG MULTI V PLUS II ■ No of compressors - MULTI V PLUS II 48HP : 6 Compressors (5.356kW+5.3kW)*3
Appendix. Load performance of Toshiba S-MMS ※ Source - Toshiba Engineering data book
Appendix. Load performance of Toshiba S-MMS ※ Source – LG MULTI V PLUS II Engineering data book