1 / 11

Plagiarism, the web and schools

Plagiarism, the web and schools. Some statistics. 2004 3,600 teenagers caught cheating on coursework (QCA) 2005 4,500 candidates penalised for malpractice in A Level/GCSE exams and coursework (27% increase) (QCA) 1,400 cases involved plagiarism

mihaly
Download Presentation

Plagiarism, the web and schools

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Plagiarism, the web and schools

  2. Some statistics • 2004 3,600 teenagers caught cheating on coursework (QCA) • 2005 4,500 candidates penalised for malpractice in A Level/GCSE exams and coursework (27% increase) (QCA) 1,400 cases involved plagiarism • 2005 QCA survey reveals many candidates are aware of cheat sites and some had 'tried' to download essays • 2006 SQA investigates 83 allegations of plagiarism compared with 41 in 2005 • 1 in 20 parents admits to giving help for GCSE coursework (The Times) • 2008 58% teachers identified internet plagiarism as a concern 55% said aid students did not have sufficient understanding of what plagiarism was and what counts as legitimate research.

  3. Coursework and plagiarism • Problems with coursework: • Ensuring standardisation between schools • Preventing plagiarism and collusion… • Actions taken by QCA • 2005 consultation on coursework • Summer 2006 recommends return to exams • Greater use of controlled conditions • Oct 2006 ends 'teacher set and marked' coursework in several GCSE subjects, replaced by controlled assessments • Actions taken by SQA • 2005 'Plagiarism – a guide for teachers and assessors' sent to all schools • 2007 SQA Quality Framework criteria updated to include requirement to‘Take steps to minimise the risk to plagiarism’ • All students receive guide 'Preparing your coursework' • Focus on designing out plagiarism opportunities in assessments

  4. Who is to blame? • Scaffolding technique 'a kind of mass plagiarism' (AQA) • Writing frames, templates, checklists lead to 'coursework cloning' (QCA) • Edexcel criticises 'teaching by numbers' • 'The outsourcing of education by schools encourages a dynamic where many parents become far too directly involved in producing their children's homework'(Furedi, Guardian 28/3/06) • 'Plagiarism peaks in years 6, 10 and 11 as pupils prepare for crucial tests'(UCL report)

  5. The web and plagiarism • Why? • Easy to copy and paste • Volume of information – harder to trace sources? • Belief that web sources do not need to be cited • How? • Essaybanks • Social networks, messageboards • Auction sites • Bespoke writing and editing services

  6. Is the web all bad news? • Web makes it easier to detect plagiarism • Powerful search engines • Specialist detection tools • Some papers are published at multiple locations – increases chances of detection • Many 'anti-plagiarism' resources online • Online plagiarism detection

  7. Online plagiarism detection • Any detection service acts as a deterrent in itself • Helps identify whether a problem exists • Can be used to offer guidance to students, rather than punishment • Automated services save time with large teaching groups

  8. Methods of detection • Search-based services • e.g. Turnitin, EVE, SafeAssign • Analyse structure and content of document, comparing it to database of web pages • Edexcel coursework scanned by Turnitin since 2005 • All JCQ bodies use Turnitin • Writing style analysis • Collusion detection • Using search engines • Common sense

  9. Limits of Electronic Detection • Technical and administrative restrictions • Format requirements • Bulk or single upload? • Cost • Data protection • Limit of coverage • Only finds web-based plagiarism • Won’t detect bespoke essay writing • Might not detect subtle word rearrangement • May falsely report plagiarism • Legitimate quoting from sources within “ ” and properly cited • Frequently occurring phrases

  10. Summary • Various automated plagiarism detection services exist • Automated detection alone can only flag up possible plagiarism • Human analysis and decisions will always be needed as well Funded by Eduserv

  11. Glossary • QCA Qualifications and Curriculum Authority. Public body maintaining national curriculum, accredits and monitors qualifications in schools and colleges • JCQ Joint Council for Qualifications. Represents all awarding bodies, compiles statistics, helps create common standards • Awarding bodies: • AQA Assessment and Qualifications Alliance. Emerged from merger of AEB and NEAB. Largest. • Also, Edexcel, UCLES and Scottish, Welsh and NI bodies

More Related