700 likes | 840 Views
A. Enterprise Content Management. 1 6/10/2014 Melodie Beveridge. Benefits of ECM for SSA. 2 6/10/2014 MB. Products We Evaluated. Alfresco Carbide CrownPeak Groupee Hot Banana Joomla Metadot SharePoint Sitecore. 3 6/10/2014 MB. We Compared. Security Ease of use
E N D
A Enterprise Content Management 1 6/10/2014 Melodie Beveridge
Benefits of ECM for SSA 2 6/10/2014 MB
Products We Evaluated • Alfresco • Carbide • CrownPeak • Groupee • Hot Banana • Joomla • Metadot • SharePoint • Sitecore 3 6/10/2014 MB
We Compared • Security • Ease of use • Product compatibility • Single sign on using LDAP • Document lifecycle management • Required 3rd party plug-ins • Features • Scalability • Cost • Documentation 4 6/10/2014 MB
Open Source Evaluation Factors • A thriving community • A handful of lead developers, a large body of contributors, and a substantial--or at least motivated--user group offering ideas. • Disruptive goals • Does something notably better than commercial code. Free isn't enough. • Documentation • What good's a project that can't be implemented by those outside its development? • Employed developers • The key developers need to work on it full time. • A clear license • Some are very business friendly, others clear as mud. • Commercial support • Companies need more than email support from volunteers. Is there a solid company employing people you can call? 5 6/10/2014 MB
Issues We Found with Some Products • Limited security • Outdated • Not LDAP friendly • Difficult to use/lacking documentation • Glorified forums/blogs • Dependence on proprietary software • Poor quality support & customer interaction • Lacking flexibility • Limited customization • Cost prohibitive 6 6/10/2014 MB
SharePoint vs. Alfresco 7 6/10/2014 MB
SharePoint • License fees are cost prohibitive • Users must have MS Office 2007 to get full functionality • Hard to use for admin • Limited to English out-of-the-box • Can configure it to permanently delete an area and all its files after a set period of inactivity • Difficult to customize and maintain • No product roadmap for the future • Microsoft does not use MOSS 2007 8 6/10/2014 MB
CMS Watch on SharePoint • The most value from enhanced Office integration will come to those enterprises concurrently upgrading to Office 2007. Customers on older versions of Office may find their usability mileage varies. • As with the previous version, ease of installation obscures difficulty in customization and ongoing maintenance; administrators can easily get in over their head. • Microsoft has not issued clear plans for subsequent releases. • Enterprise Portal Report, CMS Watch 9 6/10/2014 MB
CMS Watch on SharePoint cont. • “Microsoft has tried to go ‘enterprise’ in the impressive breadth of MOSS capabilities, but not necessarily in their depth and scalability.” • Tony Byrne, CMS Watch founder • Microsoft’s all-important consulting channel will need substantial time to absorb and learn the tool. Experience with previous versions of SharePoint suggests that this learning process will be measured in years. • Enterprise Portal Report, CMS Watch 10 6/10/2014 MB
Still no official roadmap for SharePoint 2007 • Almost 6 months after its initial launch, Microsoft has still not issued clear plans nor direction for future releases of MOSS 2007. • You can find much product information online (e.g., on security, scaling limits), but in general the documentation remains poor. The recently updated Enterprise Portals Report has many new details, including the real story on poor support for basic web standards, such as XHTML and accessibility. • Janus Boye, CMS Watch, June 4, 2007 11 6/10/2014 MB
MOSS 2007 Licensing Costs • Servers Estimated Price • Office SharePoint Server 2007 $4424 • Office SharePoint Server 2007 for Search Standard $8213 • Office SharePoint Server 2007 for Search Enterprise $57,670 • Office Forms Server 2007 $4424 • Client Access Licenses Estimated Price • Office SharePoint Server 2007 Standard CAL $94 • Office SharePoint Server 2007 Enterprise CAL $75 • Office Forms Server 2007 CAL $54 • Office SharePoint Designer 2007 $187 • Internet Facing Sites Estimated Price • Office SharePoint Server 2007 for Internet sites $40,943 • Office Forms Server 2007 for Internet sites $22,118 • To be licensed for the Enterprise Edition functionality of Office SharePoint Server 2007, both the Standard and Enterprise client access licenses are required. • office.microsoft.com / technet2.microsoft.com 12 6/10/2014 MB
MOSS 2007 Costs for SSA • 12 MS Office 2007 Enterprise licenses (needed for full functionality of MOSS2007) - $10,500 • Office SharePoint Server 2007 for Search Enterprise - $57,670 • Office Forms Server 2007 - $4424 • Office SharePoint Server 2007 Standard CAL - $94 • Office SharePoint Server 2007 Enterprise CAL - $75 • Office Forms Server 2007 CAL - $54 • Office SharePoint Designer 2007 - $187 • Office SharePoint Server 2007 for Internet sites - $40,943 • Office Forms Server 2007 for Internet sites - $22,118 Total Cost - $136,075 13 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco • No license fees • Installs with OpenOffice • Easy to use at both user and admin levels • 15 years experience with ECM • Version 2.0 contains 15 languages • Deleted items stored in archive space store. • Admin can back-up and purge periodically. • Easy to customize and maintain • Product roadmap • Wiki.alfresco.com/wiki/Roadmap • Alfresco uses their own product for consumers to access their documents • http://www.alfresco.com/community/register/?source=451%20Group%20White%20Paper 14 6/10/2014 MB
InfoWorld on Alfresco Alfresco, a highly functional open source alternative to commercial enterprise CMSes, is also simple to install, use, and manage. Drag-and-drop eases uploading and managing documents. Users employ wizards to create rules that, for example, flow documents or automatically perform conversion tasks. The system includes advanced search and threaded discussions, is scalable, and provides portal integration. • Alfresco delivers an open CMS alternative, InfoWorld 15 6/10/2014 MB
CMS Wire on Alfresco This newest offering from Alfresco is poised to deliver “simple, standards-based, distributed search encompassing not only multiple Alfresco repositories but the Internet as well. Complementing that capability is the company’s content solution packaging mechanism, Alfresco Module Packaging (AMP). Alfresco 2.0 also delivers an integrated content platform with the production release of Web Content Management and AMP-enabled Records Management.” • Alfresco Updates Open Source ECM , by Cate O'Malley 16 6/10/2014 MB
CNET News.com on Alfresco "Alfresco's use of the GPL license for its Community Edition allows for potentially greater community contributions due to license familiarity and established standards," he said. At the same time, Alfresco can continue "to focus on growing its Enterprise Edition business under a commercial license." • Raven Zachary, 451 Group analyst 17 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco About Company, Partners & Product 18 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Team • Original leading members from Documentum and Interwoven with 15 years experience in ECM • John Newton – Co-Founder of Documentum • John Powell – Former COO, Business Objects • Dr. Ian Howells – Former VP Marketing, SeeBeyond • Kevin Cochrane – Former VP Web Content Management, Interwoven • Matt Asay – Founder and Organizer of the Open Source Business Conference (OSBC) • Former Documentum Java Web Development and Portal Team • Former Interwoven TeamSite and OpenDeploy Engineers 19 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Provides • Single sign-on using LDAP • Custom security roles & permissions • Out-of-the box ease of use • Full document lifecycle management • No proprietary tie-in • Customizable • Web content management • Scalability • Good customer support/documentation • Multi-language content architecture 20 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Diversity 21 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Technologies Used • Java • Spring Aspect-Oriented Framework • ACEGI –Aspect-Oriented Security Framework • MyFaces JSF Implementation • Hibernate ORM Persistence • Lucene Text Search Engine • JLAN • POI File Format Conversion • PDFBox – PDF Conversion • OpenOffice • jBPM • Rhino JavaScript engine 22 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Supported Interfaces • CIFS/SMB Microsoft File Share Protocol • JSR-168 Portlet Specification • JSR-127 Java Server Faces • FTP • WebDAV • Web Services • REST • JBoss Portal • LifeRay 23 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Web Content Supports • DreamWeaver • PhotoShop • Eclipse • NetBeans • HTML • XSL • CSS • JSP Users can use their preferred tools when creating content 24 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Operates Using • Operating System • Linux • MacOS • Unix • Windows • Database • MySQL • Oracle • Microsoft SQL Server • Any database supported by Hibernate • Application Server • JBoss Application Server • Apache Tomcat • J2SE 5.0 (JRE 5.0) 25 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco 2.0 Offers • Open search—standards-based search across multiple Alfresco content repositories and other RSS or Atom repositories including blogs and wikis • Web content management production release—simple and rapid import of existing Web sites with support for any content authoring or Web development tool • Alfresco Module Packaging (AMP)—complete content solutions to share globally across all repositories, includes code, content model, content and folder structures • AMP-enabled records management—develop and consistently distribute records management policies according to corporate rules through AMP. 26 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Enterprise Services • Support • Maintenance, Updates and Patch support • Customer Support – Problem Resolution, Compatibility and Migration Advice • Customer Portal – Information, Bug Tracking and Case Tracking • Performance Tuning Advice • Indemnity and Warranty 27 6/10/2014 MB
Companies using Alfresco • AirBus • American Stock Exchange • Boise Cascade • Federal Aviation Association (FAA) • H&R Block • Harvard University • Knight Ridder Digital • Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) • PreVisor • Reed • State of Louisiana • State of Nebraska • Swansea Housing Association • UK Defence Academy 28 6/10/2014 MB
Company Buzz • Boise Cascade • “Alfresco offered the functionality of other Enterprise Content Management systems at a fraction of the cost.” • “Alfresco’s ability to scale-out over a number of machines further reduces the Total Cost of Ownership.” • Myron Blaine – System Architect, Boise Cascade • Knight Ridder Digital • “We believe Alfresco’s ground breaking architecture coupled with open source technologies will enable Knight Ridder Digital to create a scalable, flexible Web Content Management system that gives us great control over how we access and present our content. That is serving real-time, re-purposeable, contributions to our web sites on an internet scale”. • Dean Denhart, CTO – Knight Ridder Digital 29 6/10/2014 MB
Company Buzz cont. • Reed • “Alfresco takes ECM from the Client-Server World of the 90’s into the SOA, Web Services and Aspect Oriented World of Today” • Romain Sutton, Head of Technical Architecture - Reed Managed Services plc • State of Nebraska • “Open Source and Open Standards were critical to our decision. Alfresco was not only open source but supported key Government directions such as PDF, ODF and JSR-170” • Daren Gillespie – Network Administrator, Nebraska State Legislature 30 6/10/2014 MB
Company Buzz cont. • Swansea Housing Association • “We could clearly see the benefits of Alfresco over our existing system. We now have the ability to manage our process and workflows in ways we could only do after placing a call to our developers”. • “This represents a major opportunity to change and enhance the way we work.” • Geoff Pettifor – Director of Development, Swansea Housing Association • UK Defence Agency • “Most staff are not prepared to learn a new interface to access a repository/document management system. Hence, the system needed to appear as a shared drive that could be simply accessed via Windows Explorer and MS-Office through “drag-and-drop” and “Save-As” • Wing Commander Peter Edwards, CIO Defence Academy 31 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Technology Partners • JBoss • LifeRay • MySQL • Novell • SugarCRM • Complete listing of partners at www.alfresco.com/partners/ 32 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Ease of Use 33 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Set-Up • Chose the version to download from http://dev.alfresco.com/downloads/ • Install Alfresco on your choice of operating systems • Start Alfresco • Default setting are: • Tomcat • Hibernate • Login as admin to create user accounts 34 6/10/2014 MB
Default Login Screen 35 6/10/2014 MB
SSA Custom Login Screen • Edited 3 files 36 6/10/2014 MB
Default Admin Screen 37 6/10/2014 MB
SSA Custom Admin Screen 38 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Security 39 6/10/2014 MB
40 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Security Includes • Security and User Management with Users, Groups and Roles • Custom roles are created by editing of permissionDefinitions.xml file • Must restart Alfresco for new roles to appear • Document Level Security • Single Sign-On through NTLM or LDAP 41 6/10/2014 MB
Permissions for Spaces • ReadProperties – Read space properties • ReadChildren – Read content within a space • WriteProperties – Update properties such as title, description, etc. • DeleteNode – Delete space • DeleteChildren – Delete content & sub-spaces within a space • CreateChildren – Create content within a space Sub-spaces may inherit permissions from their parent space using a checkbox 42 6/10/2014 MB
Permissions for Content Items • ReadContent – Read file • WriteContent – Update file • ReadProperties – Read file properties • WriteProperties – Update file properties such as title, description, etc. • DeleteNode – Delete file • ExecuteContent – Execute file • SetOwner – Set ownership on a content item Roles can be applied to individual content items 43 6/10/2014 MB
Default Roles & Permissions 44 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Document Workflow 45 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Simple Workflow • Using Create Rules Wizard you • Identify spaces & set security on those spaces • Define your workflow process • Add workflow to content in those spaces • Select email template & people to receive them • Test the workflow process 46 6/10/2014 MB
Alfresco Advanced Workflow • Using JBPM (JBoss Business Process Management) engine Alfresco has two advanced workflows available out of the box • Advanced workflows allow for • Multi-state definitions • Removes restrictions to approve or reject exit transitions • Defining parallel workflows • Notion of task or assignment • Adhoc Task workflow • Assign tasks to colleagues on an ad-hoc basis • Review and Approve workflow • Assign tasks to colleagues for review and approval 47 6/10/2014 MB
Pending Assets Workflow 48 6/10/2014 MB
Adhoc Task Workflow 49 6/10/2014 MB
Review & Approve Workflow 50 6/10/2014 MB