1 / 24

Trans-national Migration

Trans-national Migration. International College Khon Kaen University 2012 Week 9 – Migration Processes: Irregular Channels . Migration Processes – Irregular.

oralee
Download Presentation

Trans-national Migration

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Trans-national Migration International College KhonKaen University 2012 Week 9 – Migration Processes: Irregular Channels

  2. Migration Processes – Irregular • In Week 8 we looked at legal channels of migration – respecting all the laws and regulations of both source country and receiving country • Irregular migration refers to any cross-border movement or action which does not conform with both countries’ laws and regulations • We generally avoid the term “illegal migration” because many irregular migrants are forced by circumstance to migrate – they don’t choose to break the law

  3. Migration Processes – Irregular • Irregular migrants include those who: • Enter another country without authorisation (no visa or entry stamp, when required) • Breach a condition of their entry visa or stamp • Do not have legal status because of loss of (destruction of) entry documentation • Other irregular migrants are clearly “illegal” because they break laws other than immigration laws

  4. Migration Processes – Illegal Migration • The term “illegal migration” is most often used to describe three situations where a conscious decision is made to break the law: • People smuggling (the migrant and the smuggler act illegally) • Human trafficking (the organizer acts illegally) • Employment of illegal workers (the employer acts illegally)

  5. Migration Processes – Irregular • As for legal migration, irregular and illegal migration are caused very largely by people from poorer countries seeking a better quality of life in more developed countries • Better quality of life can include: • More jobs and better salaries • Better educational and health services • Better housing and working conditions • Family reunification • Better protections for human rights, religious beliefs

  6. Migration Processes – Irregular • Migrants generally decide to migrate by performing a cost/benefit analysis: • What are the costs and risks of migrating, in financial, social and security terms • What are the benefits, again in financial, social and security terms • What are the chances of success? • Most often migrants choose the legal channel if this is available because this offers the least risk (best security)

  7. Migration Processes – Irregular • But for three main reasons, more and more people are being forced to migrate irregularly or illegally: • Because receiving countries are becoming more selective about who can enter, and conditions of entry • Because migrants don’t qualify for legal entry, the cost is too high or the delays are too long • Because of population growth, environmental disasters, poverty and income inequality

  8. Irregular Migration – Economic Migrants • Other cost/benefit factors affecting the decision to migrate, even if this is illegal: • Geographic proximity • Border enforcement • Probability of arrest • Consequences of being arrested • Ease of illegal employment • Chances of future legalization • Chances of future family reunification

  9. Irregular Migration – Economic Migrants • Irregular migration tends to become unstoppable when: • The financial rewards appear large because of a wide disparity in income levels • The risks of being caught, imprisoned or returned appear to be low • Any social benefits justify the risks, or social costs are acceptable given the financial benefits • Information sources are reliable so the migrant feels confident of making a sound decision

  10. Irregular Migration – Economic Migrants • Globalization processes have contributed to irregular migration flows: • Major shifts in employment patterns, especially into higher-paid services jobs in developed countries • Major shifts in global pricing, especially reduced returns from agriculture • Improved ease and flow of communications • Lower cost and ease of travel • Increasing inequality of opportunity and rewards, especially for the poorly educated

  11. Irregular Migration – Forced Migrants • Any of the “push” factors we looked at earlier can force a migrant to seek a safer life elsewhere: • War, including civil war • Persecution, ie. of a religious or ethnic minority • Environmental pressure, ie. regular floods, desertification or famine • Man-made disasters, ie. nuclear contamination, destruction of habitat, pollution

  12. Irregular Migration – Family Migrants • Most developed countries have generous immigration policies or quotas to allow close family members of permanent residents or citizens to reunite • But most middle-income countries do not allow family members to immigrate legally • In addition, irregular and temporary migrants generally have no rights to bring in their families • Family reunification is a major factor in many irregular migration decisions

  13. Irregular Migration – Processes • Most irregular migrants make no effort to obtain a passport or visa and immigrate across a land border or by hiding (in a ship, or container) • In countries where this is difficult, migrants can enter a country legally on a short-term tourist visa, then: • Undertake paid employment, and/or • Stay in the country beyond the allowed period • In both these situations, the migrant becomes “irregular” because of the breach of conditions

  14. Irregular Migration – Processes • An irregular migrant has a choice between: • Staying on irregularly until he is ready to depart, or is detained • Applying for asylum or refugee status • Applying for regular status (normally only when an amnesty is offered, and only for a temporary period) • Every country has different ways of dealing with irregular migrants, but they always make it difficult so as to encourage use of the legal migration channel

  15. Irregular Migration – Asylum Seekers and Refugees • Asylum seeker: • A person who seeks safety from persecution or serious harm in a country other than his own, awaits a decision on his application for refugee status under relevant international and national laws • Refugee: • A person who, “owing to a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinions, is outside the country of his nationality”

  16. Illegal Migration -Human Trafficking • The definition of human trafficking I gave you in Week 5: • The recruitment, transportation, harboring or transfer of a person by force, or by the threat of force, by deception, by fraud or by abuse of power • The main difference between trafficking and smuggling is that the trafficked person is not a willing partner – he/she is a victim of the crime • The other difference is that on arrival the trafficked person is not free

  17. Illegal Migration -Human Trafficking • People trafficking is a crime under international law • It is a form of modern-day slavery: the trafficked person is deprived of their freedom and rights • Often the arrangement is structured as a work contract which is highly exploitative • Other times the arrangement is structured as debt bondage

  18. Illegal Migration -Human Trafficking • Trafficking often has its roots in poverty, especially trafficking in children • Parents sell their children to pay off debts or gain income • Children may be sold to work, or for prostitution, begging, as illegal adoptions or even the removal of organs • Thailand is one of the world’s major source and transit countries for trafficking in women and children

  19. Illegal Migration -People Smuggling • People smuggling: • Organizing and facilitating the illegal entry of a person into another country in exchange for payment by that person for the service • A smuggled person is a willing participant in the crime, but is often not fully aware of the dangers and risks • A smuggled person is generally free on arrival to pursue his/her own life (if not caught by the police)

  20. Illegal Migration -People Smuggling • Smugglers are traders whose “goods” are people • Two famous groups of people smugglers are: • “Snakeheads”: Chinese gangs who smuggle people (mainly from Fujian) to many countries • “Coyotes”: the common term for smugglers operating along the Mexican/USA border • Smuggling networks may be long and complicated, or involve a single overnight border crossing or boat trip

  21. Illegal Migration -People Smuggling • Like human trafficking, people smuggling is a transnational crime • It is made possible by: • Weak legislation in many countries • Weak border controls • Corrupt officials • Power of organized crime • Sympathy from human rights groups and NGOs for those escaping hardship and persecution

  22. Illegal Migration –Trafficking and Smuggling • Human trafficking and human smuggling are growth industries offering attractive rewards • Both businesses have become entwined with other transnational crimes such as drug trafficking and money laundering • Between 300-400,000 people enter the US illegally each year • Another 800,000 enter the European Union each year • Other major destination countries: Canada, Australia, Russia and South Africa

  23. Illegal Migration –Trafficking and Smuggling • Most countries are increasing their efforts to counter these crimes through global and regional initiatives • In 2000, the UN adopted the Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime (the Palermo Convention) which has 2 protocols: • Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, especially women and children • Protocol against the Smuggling of Migrants

  24. Illegal Migration –Trafficking and Smuggling • The main UN agency working to reduce trafficking and smuggling is the UN Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) • Other UN agencies involved: • ILO • UN Women • UNICEF • Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights • Also many NGOS are active, especially the International Organization for Migration (IOM) • Progress is slow because the underlying pressure to migrate continues to increase

More Related