320 likes | 407 Views
Moving Inside the Box: The Containerization of Commodities. Jean-Paul Rodrigue Associate Professor, Dept. of Global Studies & Geography, Hofstra University, New York, USA Theo Notteboom President, Institute of Transport and Maritime Management, University of Antwerp, Belgium.
E N D
Moving Inside the Box:The Containerization of Commodities Jean-Paul RodrigueAssociate Professor, Dept. of Global Studies & Geography, Hofstra University, New York, USA Theo Notteboom President, Institute of Transport and Maritime Management, University of Antwerp, Belgium
Moving from Logistics to Commodity Chains A New Growth Dynamics for Containerization Market Potential: Hype and Reality Commodities in Containers Containerized Commodity Chains
Containerization Growth Factors A B C D
Containers are More than Boxes… • Looking inside the box • Containerization mainly viewed from the principle of flow. • Development of maritime and inland logistics: • Network and service configuration. • Maritime terminals and inland ports. • Globalization and global production networks: • Most considered perspective about the driver of container transport demand. • Global supply chains. • Global commodity chains: • An underrepresented dimension of containerization.
From Logistics to Commodity Chains Suppliers DC Inland Logistics Gateway MaritimeLogistics Global Supply Chain Intermediatehub CommodityChain Inland Logistics Inland Terminal Customers
Bulk and Containerized Shipping: An Emerging Complementarity
Bulk and Containerized Commodity Chains Bulk Commodity Chain Supplier Customer Port Point-to-Point Consolidationcenter Complementarity Container port Pendulum Services Intermodal terminal Containerized Commodity Chain
Continuous Commodity Index (CRB), Monthly Close, 1970-2009 (April) C B II III a c b I d 1 A 2 3 5 4
Continuous Commodity Index and Baltic Dry Index, 2000-2009 (2000=100)
Continuous Commodity Index and Average Container Shipping Rates, 1994-2009 (1994=100)
Containerized Cargo Flows along Major Trade Routes, 2007 Million TEUs Growth (2000-2007) 15.4 (+175%) 14.9 4.9 (+48%) Asia 19.9 33.1 USA 10.0 (+178%) 7.6 17.7 (+293%) Imports (M TEUs) 4.5 (+55%) 20.4 Europe 14.5 2.7 (+23%) Exports (M TEUs)
Shipper Growth Factors for Containerized Grain Shipments: A Matter of Price and Availability
Shipping Time between Bulk Handling and Containerization (Canadian Wheat)
The Containerized Commodities Market • A different market dynamic • Scale economies are achieved by the shipper: • Modes, terminals and corridors. • Few differences in scale economies for a producer. • Limited barriers to entry: • The entry unit is a container load. • As long as there is a containerized volume. • Double benefit: • Development of global niche markets where numerous small exporters may compete. • New economic development venues in commodity sectors which could not previously access foreign markets.
Composition of the Leased Container Fleet, 2008-09 40.6% 40.7% 31.2% 31.4% 20.4% 15.7% 21.6% 16.7% 28.9% 44.3% 27.6% 42.6%
Share of Main American International Trade Commodities Transported by Containership, 2000
Commodities in Containers • Container preparation • Containers are well adapted to handle packaged freight either directly ("floor loaded") or on pallets. • Not well adapted to handle commodities in bulk. • Shipment contamination: • Some commodities, like grains, would require a container to be thoroughly cleaned. • Require the cleaning of a container once unloaded. • The usage of dedicated containers? • Specialized containers exist for liquids and for refrigerated cargo.
Commodities in Containers • Container loading, unloading and transloading • Horizontal loading / unloading: • Complex task often requiring a panel to block the back door and hold the loose cargo. • Vertical loading / unloading: • Require specialized handling equipment. • Attractive option in situations of constant volume. • Transloading: • Usage of different modes to reach the load center (such as rail hopper cars). • Source loading: • Maintaining the integrity of some commodity chains (e.g. grains). • Shipment quality and product differentiation.
Horizontal Bulk Loading System Source: DirectIndustry
Commodities in Containers • Weight • Container loads are much lighter for conventional (mainly retail) freight than for commodities: • 10 to 14 tons per TEU. • The shipping industry prefers using larger containers (40 footers); more volume for the same handling costs. • Shipping commodities tends to rely on 20 footers: • Each load around 26 to 28 tons. • A 40 footer has a loading capacity of about 30 tons. • Load unit mismatch.
Commodities in Containers • Weight distribution • Containerships designed to accommodate a specific weight load and distribution: • 10 to 14 tons per loaded TEU are common operational considerations. • Large commodity shipments are problematic: • More than 20 tons per TEU; adjustments in the distribution of this load must be made. • A containership presented with a full load of heavy containers could only by filled to 75% of its capacity. • Trade imbalances: • Inbound full loads of relatively light containers. • Outbound heavies and empties.
Containerized Commodity Chains • Inertia • Substantial investment in bulk handling equipment. • Stakeholders reluctant to change practices. • Suitability: • New or expanding markets. • Low volume situations. • Surge in demand. • Demand mismatches • Import regions are not the same than exports regions: • Imports regions: consumption related (large metropolitan areas). • Exports regions: rural areas or resource extraction areas (low population densities). • Cargo rotation: • Permit repositioning opportunities. • Mitigate the availability of containers for exports.
Containerized Commodity Chains • Seasonality • Attribute of many commodities. • Surge in demand at specific times of the year. • Seasonality has a geography: • Harvesting time varies between different regions of the world. • Temporal and geographical fluctuations in the repositioning of empty containers. • A double-edged sword: • Surge in supply (demand for containers). • Drop in commodity price.
Conclusion: A Look Inside the Box Commodities and the Functional and Geographical Diffusion of Containerization A Complex Complementarity