200 likes | 271 Views
Visually-induced auditory spatial adaptation in monkeys and humans. Norbert Kopčo, I-Fan Lin, Barbara Shinn-Cunningham, Jennifer Groh Center for Cognitive Neuroscience, Duke University Hearing Research Center, Boston University Technical University, Košice, Slovakia. Way to go Red Sox!.
E N D
Visually-induced auditory spatial adaptation in monkeys and humans Norbert Kopčo, I-Fan Lin, Barbara Shinn-Cunningham, Jennifer Groh Center for Cognitive Neuroscience, Duke UniversityHearing Research Center, Boston UniversityTechnical University, Košice, Slovakia
Way to go Red Sox! Way to go Red Sox! Introduction • Visual stimuli can affect the perception of sound location e.g. the Ventriloquism Effect • But does effect persist? SFN 07 San Diego
Way to go Red Sox! Introduction • Visual stimuli can affect the perception of sound location e.g. the Ventriloquist Effect • But does effect persist? • - barn owls: prism adaptation (Knudsen et al.) • - monkeys: “ventriloquism aftereffect” (Woods and Recanzone, Curr. Biol. 2004) SFN 07 San Diego
GOALS • Ventriloquism “aftereffect” in saccade task, in monkeys and humans? • - well-defined sensory-motor paradigm • - bridge to barn owl prism adaptation studies (on different time scale) • Reference frame of plasticity? • - Visual, auditory, or oculomotor reference frame? SFN 07 San Diego
Methods • Basic idea: • 1. Pre-adaptation baseline: Measure auditory saccade accuracy • 2. Adaptation phase: Present combined visual-auditory stimuli, with visual location shifted • 3. Compare auditory saccade accuracy pre- and post-adaptation SFN 07 San Diego
Methods • Initial experiment: Does it work? • Design: • Monkey • Pre-adaptation baseline – ~100 Auditory-only trials • Adaptation phase – • 80% V-A stimuli, visual stimulus shifted 6 deg. Left or Right • 20% Auditory-only • Compare Auditory-only trials from adaptation phase to pre- • adaptation phase Sounds: Loudspeakers Visual stimuli: LEDs SFN 07 San Diego
RESULTS SFN 07 San Diego
RESULTS SFN 07 San Diego
RESULTS SFN 07 San Diego
RESULTS SFN 07 San Diego
Methods: reference frame ? Eye-centered? ? Oculomotor? Head (ear) -centered? SFN 07 San Diego
Expected behavior • Magnitude (°) • Stimulus Location (°) Method • Induce shift: • - in only one region of space • - from a single fixation point • Test to see if shift generalizes • to the same sub-region in: • - head-centered space • - eye-centered space • Experiment divided into • 1-hour blocks: • (12 for humans, 16 monkeys) • Within a block, 3 types of • randomly interleaved trials: • - AV 50%, • - A-only, trained FP • - A-only, shifted FP • Audiovisual display SFN 07 San Diego
Speakers • LEDs • FP • or Results: Humans • Audiovisual display • Trained FP A-only • responses: • - Shift induced in • trained sub-region • - Generalization to • untrained regions • (asymmetrical) • Magnitude of Induced Shift (°) • Shifted FP A-only • responses: • - Shift reduced in • center region • Head-centered • representation, • modulated by • eye position • Stimulus Location (°) • Expected Responses SFN 07 San Diego
Speakers • LEDs • FP • or Results: Monkeys • Audiovisual display • Trained FP A-only • responses: • - Shift in trained sub- • region weaker • - Generalization to • untrained regions • stronger • (asymmetry oppo- • site to humans) • Magnitude of Induced Shift (°) • Shifted FP A-only • responses: • - Shift decreases on • the right • - Shift increases on • the left • Stimulus Location (°) • Expected Responses • Humans: Representation more mixed SFN 07 San Diego
Summary • The main results are consistent across species: • Locally induced ventriloquist effect results in short-term adaptation, causing shifts in responses to A-only stimuli from trained sub-region. • The induced shift generalizes outside the trained sub-region, with gradually decreasing strength (However, the pattern of generalization differs across the species) • The pattern of induced shift changes as the eyes move. But, overall, it appears to be in a representation frame that is more head-centered than eye-centered. SFN 07 San Diego
Discussion • Posterior • Parietal • Cortex • Neural adaptation could have been • induced at several stages along the • Pathway (IC, MGB, AC, PPX, MC, • SC). • In humans, multiple effects • observed at different temporal • scales likely adaptation at • multiple stages • Future work • Extend Examine temporal and spatial factors influencing the eye-centered modulation. • Look at other trained sub-regions. • Cerebrum • Thalamus • Thalamus • Midbrain • Midbrain • Pons • Pons SFN 07 San Diego
Summary and discussion • the main results are consistent across species:Locally induced ventriloquist effect results in short-term adaptation, causing shifts in responses to A-only stimuli from trained sub-region.The pattern of induced shift is modified as the eyes move. • Bad news – there is a lot of differences between species: • HumansMonkeysRepresentation head-centered, eye-modulated eye-centered • Generalizationto untrained sub-regions more on the side away from FP opposite • Difference betweenhyper- and hypometricshifts no yes • Representation whenshift induced on side (data not shown) head-centered, no eye modulation eye-centered SFN 07 San Diego
Speakers • LEDs • FP Results: Humans • Audiovisual display • Human Behavior • Mean+SE • Magnitude of Induced Shift (°) • Expected Responses • Stimulus Location (°) SFN 07 San Diego
Results: Humans • Audiovisual display • Expected Responses • Human Behavior • Data collapsed across • direction of induced • shift • Speakers • LEDs • FP • Trained FP A-only • responses: • - Shift induced in • trained sub-region • - Generalization to • untrained regions • (asymmetrical) • Stimulus Location (°) • Mean+SE • Shifted FP A-only • responses: • - Shift reduced in center • region • Head-centered repre- • sentation, modulated • by eye position SFN 07 San Diego
Results: Humans vs. Monkeys • Human Behavior • Audiovisual display • Monkey Behavior • Monkey data • (only hypometric) • AV responses: • - as expected • 6 • Speakers • Mean+SE • Mean • LEDs • FP • Trained FP A-only • responses: • - Shift in trained sub- • region weaker • - Generalization to • untrained regions • stronger • (asymmetry opposite • to humans) • 6 • -24 0 24 • Mean+SE • Mean+individuals • -24 0 24 • Shifted FP A-only • responses: • - Shifted with eyes • Representation more • eye-centered • Mean+individuals • Mean+SE • -24 0 24 SFN 07 San Diego