400 likes | 428 Views
Building Leadership Skills: Problem-Solving and Decision-Making. An Infopeople Workshop Presented by Joan Frye Williams www.jfwilliams.com. Not All Decisions Require Equal Attention. Decision Insurance. Define the problem Gather additional data Lay it all out Identify your options
E N D
Building Leadership Skills:Problem-Solving and Decision-Making An Infopeople Workshop Presented by Joan Frye Williams www.jfwilliams.com
Decision Insurance • Define the problem • Gather additional data • Lay it all out • Identify your options • Evaluate your options • Make your decision • Move forward
Step #1:Define the Problem • What? • Where? • How? • When? • With whom? • Why?
For a Complex Problem • Break it down • Verify with others • Prioritize
Describe the Desired Outcome(s) Define the solved state: Here’s what should be happening…
Identify Specific, Measurable Goals What are we trying to • Achieve? • Preserve? • Avoid? • Eliminate?
Link Back to the Big Picture Make sure your desired outcomes align clearly with the library’s mission and strategic plan
Reality Check:Decision Politics • Who are the stakeholders in this situation? • What will they need to get out of any decision? • How and when should they participate in finding a solution?
Step #2:Gather Additional Data • Broad • Objective • Verifiable • Relevant
Beware • Hearsay/rumor • Opinion • Wishful thinking • Labeling the problem • Blaming/scapegoating • Vivid but minor evidence
Don’t Overlook • Your own beliefs and biases • Your own (possible) role in the situation
Just Be Sure YouCover the Bases • Bouncing around is natural • More information may accrue over time
Pareto Analysis • “80/20 rule” • Focus on numerical data • Use to identify which situations are most common
Mind Mapping • Free-form note taking • Any kind of information • Use to show how different facts relate to the problem and to each other
Look into Causes but Don’t Bog Down • Not all problems are “caused” • Not all causes can be corrected Ask for input – one person at a time.
The Un-Problem:Appreciative Inquiry • Systematic discovery of the best in people and organizations • Unconditional positive questions • Directed conversation and storytelling • What is working well? • How can we do more of that?
Step #4:Identify Your Options • What options do we have? • What has been done in other libraries? • In other disciplines? • How about something new?
Situation:Something’s Gone Wrong • Find and correct the changes that account for the fall-off in results.
Situation:Increased – or Changing – Expectations • Find new ways of operating.
Situation:The Double Whammy • Find ways to reengineer the system – correct and invent.
Situation:It Never Did Work Right • Find ways to overhaul – or completely rebuild.
Things That Can Limit Your Thinking • Searching for THE ONE RIGHT ANSWER • Not involving front line people • Looking inside the library only • Waiting for 100% agreement • Fear of embarrassment or failure
Be Sure to Include • Current approach • Something new • Something fun
SWOT: Strengths – Weaknesses – Opportunities – ThreatsPMI:Plus – Minus - Interesting
Think Through Risks and Consequences • Reversible? • Pilot-able? • Timely? • Politically sensitive?
Special Challenges in Many Library Environments • Perfectionism • Catastrophizing • Mixed feelings about success
Reality Check:Strategic Thinking • How might this decision change the library’s position or reputation? • Will it set the stage or define a pattern for future decisions? • Do library stakeholders need a heads-up? • Who will get credit if things turn out well?
Step #7:Move Forward • Communicate the decision/solution • Plan the implementation • Monitor results • Learn as you go
When Things Go Wrong • Work each problem • Re-prioritize if necessary • Maintain focus on desired outcomes • After a fair trial, change options