170 likes | 320 Views
Professor Dave Adamson Centre for Regeneration Excellence Wales. The Policy Context. Area based regeneration Policy similarities and divergence Variation in delivery models Variation in governance patterns. The Devolution Context. Four administrations Different devolved powers
E N D
Professor Dave Adamson Centre for Regeneration Excellence Wales Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Policy Context • Area based regeneration • Policy similarities and divergence • Variation in delivery models • Variation in governance patterns Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolution Context • Four administrations • Different devolved powers • Northern Ireland suspensions • Autonomy in regeneration policy field Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Limitations of the Project • Personal overview • Limited case studies • Not an evaluation Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
Research Issues • Attribution of impact on poverty • Poverty as income poverty • Social exclusion • The ‘lived experience of poverty’ Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
Assessing impact of regeneration: a personal view • Atmosphere • Landscape • Horizon Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: Northern Ireland • New TSN • Lifetime Opportunities • Neighbourhood Renewal Strategy Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: Northern Ireland: An assessment • A fractured process • Failure of ‘bending’ • Failure of integration of policy • No change in atmosphere, landscape or horizon Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: Wales • Communities First • Programme for a ‘generation’ • Recently linked to local targets and Wales child poverty objectives Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: Wales: an assessment • Successful community engagement • Failure of ‘bending’ • Failure to link with mainstream policies • Changed atmosphere, failure to change landscape and horizon Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: Scotland • Social Justice: A Scotland where everyone matters • Social Inclusion Partnerships • Community Planning Partnerships • The Community Regeneration Fund • The Fairer Scotland Fund Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: Scotland: an assessment • The role of housing renewal • Effective partnership in SIPS • Failure of ‘bending’ • The demise of community involvement? • The dilution of area-based regeneration? Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: Scotland: an assessment • Improvements in atmosphere • Improvements in landscape • No significant change to horizon Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: England • New Deal for Communities • Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal • Associated programmes and funding streams • Working Neighbourhoods Fund Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: England: assessing impact • NDC positive evaluation: local and national • More limited success in health, education and worklessness • NDC and NMP good at community engagement • Evidence of bending and mainstreaming Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The Devolved Policies: Scotland: an assessment • Improvements in atmosphere • Improvements in landscape • Change to horizon Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge
The impact of policies: an overview • The value of area-based regeneration • Balancing local and national interventions • The need for bending, mainstreaming and service improvement • The need to change horizons Tackling Multiple Deprivation: the ongoing challenge