110 likes | 295 Views
Effects of Variation on Emerging Devices for Use in SRAM. Greg LaCaille and Lucas Calderin. SRAM Power Consumption. Minimum operating supply voltage ( Vmin ) determined by: Minimum acceptable Ion/ Ioff ratio Effects of performance variation on read and write margins
E N D
Effects of Variation on Emerging Devices for Use in SRAM Greg LaCaille and Lucas Calderin
SRAM Power Consumption • Minimum operating supply voltage (Vmin) determined by: • Minimum acceptable Ion/Ioff ratio • Effects of performance variation on read and write margins • As CMOS is scaled down both these values typically get worse. • Reducing Vmin will lower power consumption • SRAM assist techniques typically target improving variation tolerance contribution. • Device selection can affect the contribution from leakage requirements.
Fully Depleted CMOS • UTB-SOI or FinFET • Similar to Bulk CMOS • Gate control over entire channel reduces sub-threshold swing • DIBL reduced relative to Bulk but still present
Carbon Nano-tube FETs • Ballistic transport • Saturation determined by contact resistance • Intrinsic channel more similar to BJT than MOSFET • Little-to-No DIBL
Tunneling FETs • Band to Band tunneling current • Capable of sub-threshold swing < 60mV/dec • Low on current relative to MOS device of similar size • Little-to-No DIBL n-type
SRAM Leakage • For a SRAM with m rows where A is the desired margin • m=256; A=4 • There is a minimum Vdd where this can be satisfied
Read/Write Failure • Script written to simulate DC sweeps while sweeping variation in each transistor • Automatic detection of read and write failures
Variation Limits • Each point represents a read or write failure • X axis is the average Vth of all the devices in the point that failed • Y axis is the rms sum of the difference in Vth for each device from the average Vth for the point • Area below the curve represents successful cells
Variation Limits • For all devices the maximum allowable variation increased with Vdd as expected • The allowable deviation at the lowest Vth to satisfy leakage requirements deviates among the devices substantially
Conclusion • Improved Ion/Ioff for the TFET doesn’t necessarily improve Vmin due to variation • CNFET is comparable to FD CMOS • Minimum access time will also play a key role in design of the SRAM • Any of these devices could be used with SRAM assist circuits to improve variability tolerance