1 / 34

TheNorth American Model of Wildlife Conservation: Relic or Relevant?

TheNorth American Model of Wildlife Conservation: Relic or Relevant?. John F. Organ John E. McDonald U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service University of Massachusetts, Amherst. North American Wildlife Conservation Precepts.

sloan
Download Presentation

TheNorth American Model of Wildlife Conservation: Relic or Relevant?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. TheNorth American Model of Wildlife Conservation:Relic or Relevant? John F. Organ John E. McDonald U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service University of Massachusetts, Amherst

  2. North American Wildlife Conservation Precepts • Wildlife is a public resource: governments conserve for future generations • Wildlife has value when alive • Uncontrolled use leading to decline & extinction unacceptable • Wildlife can be used sustainably

  3. Principles of Use • Use serves a practical purpose • Species or Population is not threatened or endangered • Method of take is considered acceptable

  4. Pre-1901 • Charles Hallock • Founded Forest & Stream magazine • George Bird Grinnell • Bought out Hallock and continued his theme • Concept of the Code of the Sportsman • Boone & Crockett Club 1887 • First organization to deal with national scale conservation issues

  5. Roosevelt Era • After McKinley assassinated September 1901 Theodore Roosevelt becomes President • Begins to implement, at a national scale, the conservation ideas developed in concert with Grinnell • 1908 Governor’s Conference on Conservation • “Conservation as a National Duty”

  6. 1930 AMERICAN GAME POLICY • Land acquisition • Partnerships:Landowners/ Hunters/Public • Experiment state-by-state ways partnership yields management • Research (find facts) • Joint conservation program with hunters and protectionists together with scientists and landowners • Establish wildlife management profession • Adequate, equitable, secure $

  7. 1930’s Conservation Milestones • Duck Stamp Act • Cooperative Wildlife Research Units • Beginning of North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference and The Wildlife Society • Wildlife Restoration Act (Pittman - Robertson) • Established secure funding stream based on user-pay idea • Protected state license funds • Promoted development of wildlife science

  8. North American Model:Origin of a Concept

  9. NA Model:Origin of a Concept • As Wildlife Conservation emerged in North America a distinct form developed • 7 Components essentially define the Concept • The 7 Components or Principles are not all unique to North America, but their collective association is • The NA Model is flexible and adaptable, yet true to underlying principles

  10. North American Model of Wildlife Conservation • Wildlife as Public Trust Resources • Elimination of Markets for Game • Allocation of Wildlife by Law • Wildlife can only be killed for a Legitimate Purpose • Wildlife is considered an International Resource • Science is the proper tool for discharge of Wildlife Policy • Democracy of Hunting

  11. North American Model of Wildlife Conservation • Geist, V., and I. McTaggart-Cowan. 1995. Wildlife Conservation Policy Detselig Press, Calgary, AB • Geist, V., S.P. Mahoney, and J.F. Organ. 2001. Why Hunting Has Defined the North American Model of Wildlife Conservation Trans. North Amer. Wildl. Natur. Res. Conf. 66:175-185. • Geist, V., and J.F. Organ. 2004. The Public Trust Foundation of the North American Model of Wildlife Conservation Northeast Wildlife, 58:49-56. • Prukop, J., and R.J. Regan. 2005. The Value of the North American Model of Wildlife Conservation – an IAFWA Position Wildl. Soc. Bull. 33:374-377.

  12. http://issuu.com/the-wildlife-professional/docs/twpfall2010

  13. 1. Wildlife as Public Trust Resources

  14. The Public Trust Doctrine • U.S. Supreme Court Ruling in 1842 • Magna Carta 1215 • Roman Law 2nd Century A.D. • Ancient Greek Natural Law

  15. Solidifying the Public Trust • Concept of a Public Legal Right • Enforceable against the Government • Consistent with Contemporary Concerns

  16. Public Trust as Law(where the rubber meets the road) • Public Trust is Common Law (Judge-made Law) • Public Trust is State Law • Public Trust is Property Law

  17. Solidifying the Public Trust • Government’s general obligation to act in public interest vs. greater obligation as a trustee • Does PTD equate to a judicially enforceable right? • Should it be illegal to reduce a free-ranging live amphibian or reptile to private ownership?

  18. 2. Elimination of Markets for Game • “Commons” Theory • Rapid declines when value placed on dead wildlife

  19. Elimination of Markets for Game • Traditional Game Animals vs. Amphibians and Reptiles?

  20. Elimination of Markets for Game • American Alligator Conservation and the Market • Overabundant species? Deer, geese, nutria?

  21. 3. Allocation of Wildlife by Law • Wildlife are not allocated by market, birth right, land ownership, or special privilege • Public input into allocation provides opportunity for all citizens to be involved in wildlife management • Secures the Trust for future generations

  22. Allocation of Wildlife by Law

  23. 4. Wildlife can only be killed for a Legitimate Purpose • Food, Fur, Self-Defense, Property Protection • Laws define acceptable purpose for take • Code of sportsman mandates use without waste

  24. Wildlife can only be killed for a Legitimate Purpose We don’t afford all species and taxa equal standing….

  25. 5. Wildlife is an International Resource • Recognition that wildlife transcend boundaries • One Nation’s management can affect the other’s resources • C. Gordon Hewitt • CITES

  26. Wildlife Considered an International Resource • Do we really consider wildlife an international resource, or are we really just trying to make sure our neighbors don’t shoot our ducks before we get a chance? • Species that are relatively abundant overall in North America are listed under US ESA

  27. 6. Science is the Proper Tool for Discharge of Wildlife Policy

  28. Roosevelt Doctrine • Recognized “Outdoor Resources” as one integral whole • “Conservation through wise use” a public responsibility, and private ownership a public trust • Recognized science as a tool for discharging that responsibility, repeated later by Leopold

  29. Science as an Effective Tool • Adaptive Management approaches • Adaptive Resource Management • Adaptive Harvest Management • Adaptive Impact Management • Learning Through Management!

  30. Science is proper tool for discharging Wildlife Policy? • Politics will almost always supercede science • Science must be effective in influencing the political landscape

  31. 7. Democracy of Hunting • Regardless of Land Ownership, Birthright, or Special Privilege • Abide by Societal Rules (Laws, Regulations) • North America: broad interest in maintaining wildlife (all are stakeholders)

  32. Democracy of Hunting • Reduced access to land • Increased fee-based hunting • Shrinking societal support • Wildlife as pests rather rather than resources

  33. Do All Wildlife Fall Within the NA Model? • YES, but…….. • Social, Institutional, and Cultural barriers inhibit full embrace • Closing the Gap requires: • Broad-based non-user-pay funding – State and Federal • Greater public awareness and appreciation • Furthering the partnerships (e.g., PARC) • Trusteeship in governance

More Related