170 likes | 255 Views
Report on The STATE of HEALTH of MUMBAI July 2013. Supported by. FORD FOUNDATION. MADHU MEHTA FOUNDATION. First the Good News. Malaria. From a high in 2010-11 of one in every 158 person suffering with Malaria i n 2012-13 it was brought down to one in every 567. Data as per RTI
E N D
Report onThe STATE of HEALTH of MUMBAIJuly 2013 Supported by FORD FOUNDATION MADHU MEHTA FOUNDATION
Malaria From a high in 2010-11 of one in every 158 person suffering with Malaria in 2012-13 it was brought down to one in every 567. • Data as per RTI • Population taken as per census 2011 the population taken is 1,24,32,830
But other diseases/ailments are threatening … • Dengue • At least one in 2,555 people in Mumbai had dengue during 2012-13 • Tuberculosis • In the past 5 years, at least 40,000 people in Mumbai have died of TB • Cholera • In the past three years (2009-2011) 8 people died of cholera in Mumbai. In 2012-13 alone, cholera took 9 lives • are all on the rise…
Dengue (as per RTI data) One in every 18230 persons had dengue in 2008-09. Every year it has been dipping and now last year in 2012-13 one out of every 2555 person had dengue. • Data as per RTI • Population taken as per census 2011 the population taken is 1,24,32,830
Tuberculosis (as per RTI data) One in every 341 persons had tuberculosis in 2012-13. Mortality due to Tuberculosis is one in every five cases in 2012-13. In the last five years (2008-09) 39,531 people have died in Mumbai due to TB. • Data as per RTI • Population taken as per census 2011 the population taken is 1,24,32,830
Cholera (as per RTI data) Compared to 129,509 cases in 2008-09 one in every 62,792 person had cholera in 2012-13. Mortality rate was one in 7 cases in 2008-09. It improved to one in 62 in 2009-10. But has now again dipped to one in every 22 in 2012-13. • Data as per RTI • Population taken as per census 2011 the population taken is 1,24,32,830
Medical facilities used by citizens 31% of Mumbaikars use only government dispensary/hospital facilities. Even in lower economic strata usage of Private & Charitable facilities is high [SEC D (65%), SEC E (46%)]. Data as per Praja’s citizen survey 2013
Estimated % of annual income spent on hospital/medical costs The households spending more than 6% of annual income on hospital/medical costs are maximum in lower socio-economic strata i.e. in SEC E (59%) followed by SEC C (56%), SEC D (54%), SEC B (54%) and are least in SEC A (53%). Data as per Praja’s citizen survey 2013
Estimated cases per 1000 households The top most strata of socio-economic class (SEC A) had more cases per 1000 households of Malaria, Dengue, Diabetes; while for cancer SEC B had more cases per 1000 households. Data as per Praja’s citizen survey 2013
Deliberations on healthby Councillors during March’12 to March’13 • 34 elected (councillors) members of the Public Health have asked only 56 questions on health in 16 meetings. • 11 of them have not asked a single question. • In various committee (GBM, Ward, etc.) meetings a total of 200 questions were raised on health by 227 councillors. • 138 out of 227 have not raised a single issue on health.
Deliberations on health by 32 (excluding 4 ministers) MLAs during Budget’12, Monsoon’12 & Winter’12 sessions • Total of 780 questions were raised of which 446 were related to Mumbai or to Schemes/Policies on health, rest were related to other parts of the state not having direct implication to health policies, programmes, schemes in Mumbai. • MLAs, BaldevKhosa and Milind Kamble have not asked a single question, while Annie Shekhar, ChandrakantHandore and Kripashankar Singh have asked only a single question on health.
Inferences … • If the government had access to information from the non-government sector healthcare practitioners • Private and Charitable Clinics/Dispensaries • Private and Charitable Hospitals • Private Pathological Laboratories • Government will be able to collect more robust and rich data across the city and across demographics • Which would enable the government to create more meaningful, effective and efficient health programme, scheme and policy
What needs to be done • Public Health Surveillance (Health Information System) needs to be immediately augmented • Government must establish through legislative process a mechanism to regularly collect health data from private and charitable health facilities • Government needs to focus on primary healthcare and extend its reach and efficiency to cater towards fulfilling needs of lowest strata of socio-economic (SEC E) households • Tailor-made health awareness campaigns need to be designed to reach different socio-economic classes for greater impact
THANK YOU Questions