210 likes | 403 Views
E N D
1. The Application of Ecological
Principles to Accelerate Reclamation
of Drill Well Pads
2009 PAW Oil and Gas Reclamation Conference
Ed Redente and Cindy Pappas
MWH, Inc.
3665 JFK Parkway
Fort Collins, CO 80525
4. Drill Pad Reclamation in Northwest Colorado Current Challenges
Arid conditions and highly variable year to year precipitation
Invasive species dominate large tracts
of land
5. Overall Objective of the Study Identify techniques that will improve the success of reclamation efforts on natural gas well pads in northwest Colorado
6. Ecological Approach to TreatmentSelection Ecological Processes &
Modifying Factors
Seed Dispersal & Seedbed Preparation
Nutrient Availability & Reverse Fertilization
Environmental Stress & Species-Rich Mixtures
Interference & Annual Cover Crop
Surface depressions retain moisture at the surface longer
Have more favorable atmospheric and temperature regimes
Trap seeds and organic matter more effectively than smooth soil surface
Weedy species (ex. cheatgrass, kochia) are more advantageous in high nutrient environments.
The addition of a C source (ex. wood chips) reduces the amount of available N to plants.
Plant diversity is higher when fertilizer is withheld
Environmental conditions vary from site to site and year to year.
Seed mixes with high species richness are more likely to have species with germination requirements that meet current site conditions and could prevent invasive species of the same functional guild.
Cover crops help reduce erosion, provide organic matter, and interfere with invasive species.
Native annuals simulate a cover crop.
Native annuals will occupy space until the perennial species establish.Surface depressions retain moisture at the surface longer
Have more favorable atmospheric and temperature regimes
Trap seeds and organic matter more effectively than smooth soil surface
Weedy species (ex. cheatgrass, kochia) are more advantageous in high nutrient environments.
The addition of a C source (ex. wood chips) reduces the amount of available N to plants.
Plant diversity is higher when fertilizer is withheld
Environmental conditions vary from site to site and year to year.
Seed mixes with high species richness are more likely to have species with germination requirements that meet current site conditions and could prevent invasive species of the same functional guild.
Cover crops help reduce erosion, provide organic matter, and interfere with invasive species.
Native annuals simulate a cover crop.
Native annuals will occupy space until the perennial species establish.
7. Study Site Characteristics Pad Characteristics
Two plant community types: Pinon-Juniper and Sagebrush-Greasewood
Five pads total (3 in Sagebrush-Greasewood and 2 in Pinon-Juniper)
Elevation ranges: 1609 1789 meters (5278 5870 ft)
Average annual precipitation = 12 inches
Total pad area ranges: 0.56 0.78 hectares (1.38 1.93 acres)
8. Reclamation Treatments Tested
Treatments
2 Tillage treatments
2 Amendment treatments
2 Seeding methods
2 Seed mixtures
9. Treatments (plots 20 x 40 ft)
Rough vs. Smooth
4 catchments or basins per plot
1 ft deep, 3 ft long, 6 ft wide
25% of surface area of plot
Soil Amendment
Wood chips at 45 tons/acre
Incorporated to 6 inches
Seeding Method
Island broadcasting (forbs and shrubs separated from grasses)
Traditional broadcasting (all life forms in same seed mixture)
Seed Mixtures
Perennials only
Annuals and perennials combined
10. Plot Construction Photos
11. Plot Construction Photos
12. 2007 ppt 53% of average
2008 ppt 104% of average2007 ppt 53% of average
2008 ppt 104% of average
13. Plant Cover Summer 2008
21. Summary Cover of seeded species showed a significant increase between 1st and 2nd growing seasons
Use of annual species did not facilitate the establishment of seeded perennials
Use of catchments/basins significantly increased cover of seeded species
Use of wood chips significantly reduced cover or non-native species
Use of island broadcasting resulted in greater cover of noxious species