181 likes | 467 Views
Fire Sprinkler International 2014 Name: Andreas Teckenburg London, 20. May 2014. Fire Protection Solutions for Transformers „ TrafoProtect “ by Minimax. Agenda. Initial Situation Goal setting Trials Fire Extinguishing Concept TrafoProtect. „The risk “. 1) Initial Situation.
E N D
Fire Sprinkler International 2014 Name: Andreas Teckenburg London, 20. May 2014 • FireProtection Solutions for Transformers„TrafoProtect“ by Minimax 8 von 36
Agenda • Initial Situation • Goal setting • Trials • FireExtinguishingConceptTrafoProtect 9 von 36
„The risk“ • 1) Initial Situation • Protectivegoals: • Avoiddamagetopersons • Reducedamagetoenvironment • Reducebusinessinterruptions • Protect material asset • Avoidlossofimage • Obtainjobs • Malfunctionmechanismsoftransformers: • Mechanicalloadbyforcesofelectricalshortage in windings • Electricalloadby transient excessvoltage • Mechanicaldefectsoftheloadlevelswitch • Defectof a conduct • Thermicalorelectricalagingoftheisolators 10 von 36
Different Guidelines/ Rules • 1) Initial Situation • European Approach: • VdS 2109 VdS-Richtlinien für Sprühwasser-Löschanlagen, Planung und Einbau • TS 14816 European technical Specification, Fixed fire fighting systems - Water spray systems - Design, installation and maintenance • US Approach: • NFPA 15 Water Spray fixed systems for fire Protection • NFPA 11 Low-, medium- and high Expansion foam system • FM 4-1N Fixed water spray systems for fire protection • FM 5-04 Transformers 10 von 36
Different design parameters • 1) Initial Situation national / international • VdS 2109 (12.4): • Waterapplication: 15 - 30 mm/min • Operating time: 5 min (Step-in-time ofthefiredepartment) • NFPA 15 (7.4.4): • Waterapplicationtransformerandaccessories: 10,2 mm/min • „Endangeredterrainsurface“: 6,1 mm/min • Operating time: „As longastheexpositionstops.“ • NFPA 11 Schaumlöschanlagen: • Protectionoftansformerswith medium foam. Nodesigning. • FM DS 5-04: • In rooms (2.2.1.2.2) withsprinklerat15 mm/min or FM-approved„Machineprotectivesystem“. 12 von 36
Agenda • Initial Situation • Goal Setting • Trials • FireExtinguishingConceptTrafoProtect 9 von 36
2) Goal Setting „Creationof a protectionconcept valid andcertifiedinternationallywhichenablesthe „economicallypriced“ fireprotectionoffree-standing transfordermswithpreferablysmall design parameter.“ • Protectionoftransformers; also for„decentral“ substations (municipial utilities, etc.) Influenceof wind ? • Ifnosufficientwatersupply (amount, pressure) isexisting (existence, newbuilding) • Protectionoftransformerswithlessextinguishingwater. Mostlythetransformeristhe „waterdetermining“ component in thewholeproject. • Reducingof „contaminated“ extinguishingwater. • „The Scope“ 11 von 36
InspectionandCertificationofthe Installation Engineering • 2) Goal setting Courseoftheprocedure: • Collocationofinformationandrequirementsofthetestingcenters, but also theoperatorsandinsurer (e.g. HDI Gerling) • Preparationof a testconceptbyDMT • Set-up DMT / UL • ExecutionofthetestsatDMT • Creationoftheplanningandinstallationinstructions 12 von 36
Agenda • Initial Situation • Goal Setting • Trials • FireExtinguishingConceptTrafoProtect 9 von 36
T1 und T3 F3 T4 T2 T1 und 3 T2 F2 F1 T1 und T3 T4 • Experimental assembly in thefiretunnelat DMT, Dortmund • 3) Trials • Lateral view • Topview Size ofthe „Mock-up“: 2,8 x 2,2 x 2,5 m (W x D x H) Wind direction
3) Trials • Experimental assembly in thefiretunnelat DMT, Dortmund
Firetestsandresults (genericexample) • 3) Trials • Trial goal: Firesuppression • Puddle, Stream and spray fireunder different conditions • Nozzlesinstalled on onesideonly in thetrial; safetyfactor • Nozzlepressureandwaterquantitywerelower in thetrialsthan in thespecific design rule
3) Trials • Impressionsofthefiretests
Agenda • Initial Situation • Goal Setting • Trials • FireExtinguishingConceptTrafoProtect 9 von 36
The Minimax ProtectionConcept • 4) FireExtinguishingConceptTrafoProtect • Transformer isregardedas „lost“ in caseoffire • Firesuppression/ Firecontrol; noextinguishingnecessary • No „special“ components; e.g. high-pressurewaterfog = stainlesssteel, filter, „specialfittings“ • Certificateswithoutsizerestriction, testingunder „influenceof wind“ !!International: UL VerificationDeutschland: DMT Eignungsbestätigung • Waterapplicationwithsafetyfactorislowerthanaccordingtotheguideline
4) FireExtinguishingConceptTrafoProtect • ApprovalandCertification • Components are allUL listed • Trial resultsacceptedbyUL and DMT • Specificplanningandinstallationinstructionschecked an acceptedby UL und DMT
Thankyouforyourattention! Andreas TeckenburgDivision Energy