130 likes | 722 Views
Theories. Essentialism Perennialism Progressivism Critical Theory. Essentialism. Emphasizes fundamental, basic skills and subjects (“back to the basics” theory) American educational problems may be solved by Keeping schools on task
E N D
Theories Essentialism Perennialism Progressivism Critical Theory
Essentialism • Emphasizes fundamental, basic skills and subjects (“back to the basics” theory) • American educational problems may be solved by • Keeping schools on task • Teaching skills and subjects systematically and sequentially • Insisting on high standards for promotion and graduation • Emphasizing that learning requires discipline, effort and hard work
Essentialism Key Events • Basic Education revival of 1970s and 1980s • A Nation at Risk(1983) • Standards Movement of 1990s and 2000s • No Child Left Behind (Federal Education Act of 2001)
Essentialism Education Implications • Subject-based curriculum differentiated and organized according to subjects’ internal logic or chronology • Disciplines must be taught within a specific scope (critical of interdisciplinary approaches) • Must follow a specific sequence • Curriculum should be cumulative • Organize like a ladder with each rung preparing students for the next • Schools and teachers should stay on task, not solve outside problems
Perennialism • People possess and share a common nature that defines them as human beings • Follows Aristotle and Aquinas (Realism) • Rationality of human nature in all times and places • All people may find universal truth and live according to its values • Study classic literature and arts to discover enduring truth and beauty
Perennialism Education • School is an intellectual agency with a primary purpose to develop human reason (greatest happiness comes from exercising and applying reason) • Education should be universal, leading students to discover truth and make logical choices accordingly • Support a general curriculum, not a specialized one, based on valuable skills and subject matter • Critical of “presentism” and specialization that comes too early (general, liberal education should come first)
Progressivism • Name derived from an interest in reforming society through “progress” • Progressive reforms • Are nonviolent • Follow known and accepted procedures (generally public and formal, though some progressives advocate informal and less public) • Begin with existing situations (as opposed to beginning with ideal or utopian conditions) • Are gradual, serial and cumulative • Dissention exists within its ranks
Progressivism Education Generally divided into two camps: Child-Centered and Social Reconstructionist Child-Centered • Curriculum should grow from child’s own interests, free from imposition of traditional curriculum • Guided by permissive, encouraging teachers, children explore their environment, which enlarges their horizons • Children collaborate and discover new ways to shape democratic society Reconstructionist • Children should be used as a deliberate agency of social, political and economic reform • Schools and teachers should deal with important contemporary issues, regardless of how controversial they might be • Goal is building a better, more equitable society
Progressivism Education (continued) Generally oppose • Formal, routine instruction • Prescribed curriculum • Competitive situations • Teaching for test preparation • Extrinsic incentives Generally favor • Activities encouraging initiative, creativity & self-expression • Curriculum based on experiences • Collaborative learning • Teachers as facilitators • Whole-child education
Critical Theory • Generally derived from postmodernism and liberation pedagogy • Goals to raise consciousness and transform education and society • Focused on empowering those who have been disenfranchised • Self-determination is possible if people become conscious of and overthrow the forces that exploit them • Asks questions like, “Who controls?” and “Who benefits?” of society’s institutions, especially education
Critical Theory Education • First goal is making the oppressed aware of their condition • Must deconstruct texts, expose methods of domination and empower the dispossessed • Societal values should be derived from an authentic conversation in which all individuals have an equal voice • Teachers must encourage students to express their beliefs and concerns and facilitate conversations that lead to a realization that values are diverse, not universal • Teachers should be empowered, finding allies and joining others in the community to expose issues and bring about changes • Curriculum should grow from children’s own stories and experiences, leading to exploration of problems and knowledge for solving them, ultimately emancipating those who have been dominated