1 / 17

Constitution, Society, and Leadership

Week 4 Unit 4 History of Law: Category III: Positive/Realist Law Based on Reason. Constitution, Society, and Leadership. Category III- i Unit Introduction- i. This Unit looks at theories whose foundation is legal positivism or realism based on reason As noted in an earlier presentation,

Download Presentation

Constitution, Society, and Leadership

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Week 4 Unit 4 History of Law: Category III: Positive/Realist Law Based on Reason Constitution, Society, and Leadership

  2. Category III-iUnit Introduction-i • This Unit looks at theories whose foundation is legal positivism or realism based on reason • As noted in an earlier presentation, • Positivist and realist theories tend to be based on the will of the legislator or the judge • But there are some exceptions • With an emphasis on reason rather than will

  3. Category III-iiUnit Introduction-ii • This Unit looks at three of those exceptions • Common Law against Natural Law • The English Constitutional Tradition • Law as the Basic Law of the Constitution

  4. Category III-iiiCommon Law vs. Natural Law-i • Recall James 1 and Francis Bacon who defend • Natural law over common law • King’s prerogative over parliamentary sovereignty • Sir Edward Coke (d.1634) • Contemporary of James and Bacon • Rejects royal prerogative • Emphasizes the judicial function of parliament

  5. Category III-ivCommon Law vs. Natural Law-ii • Moves between positivism and realism • Main point: parliament subject to limits of common law • Which becomes valid only through the court’s decision • So, judicial review of legislative acts is legitimate • Like the decision in Marbury v. Madison

  6. Category III-vEnglish Constitutional Tradition-i • The English Constitutional Tradition • Combination of natural law and legal positivism • With emphasis on reason • Two major representatives • Richard Hooker (d. 1600) • Thomas Smith (d. 1577)

  7. Category III-viEnglish Constitutional Tradition-ii • Hooker • Law=“a directive rule onto goodness of operation” • A dictate of reason • Foundation for constitutionalism • Thomas Smith creates specific methods for it • “Law” encompasses both rules and rights • Tries to defend church government against Puritan critics

  8. Category III-viiEnglish Constitutional Tradition-iii • Tries to fit Aquinas’ views into Anglican Protestantism • Aquinas: A rational ordered universe couched in natural law • Hooker: “Law as a coherent system of the world as a whole” • Four sorts of law- held together by reason: • Unalterable • God’s eternal law • Natural law • Violable • Law of angels • Human law • Law of reason • Statutory law • Customary law • International law

  9. Category III-viiiEnglish Constitutional Tradition-iv • Replaces papal authority with political authority • Anglican and Lutheran: Prince as the head of the Church • Belief in free will • Center of his argument • “The laws of well-doing are the dictates of right reason” • No one knowingly does the bad or the false • “The most certain token of evident goodness is that the general persuasion of all men do so account it” • As the assent of God himself • Where else would all get the same idea?

  10. Category III-ixEnglish Constitutional Tradition-v • Sum: Law =“The basic constitutional order, resting on popular consent; from it all other laws derive their obligatory consent” • Hooker’s theory of a legal community • “Its validity rests upon the rational insights of men into the nature of human ‘living together’” • Therefore, the necessary duty of obedience

  11. Category III-xEnglish Constitutional Tradition-vi • Sir Thomas Smith • Distinguishes English law from Roman Law • Like Fortescue • “Every Englishman is present in parliament—by the person or delegates” • So consent of parliament=consent of everyone • Separation of powers: legislative, executive, judicial • Question remains: who has last word when King and parliament disagree?

  12. Category III-xiBasic Law of the Constitution-i • Law as the Basic Law of the Constitution • Combination, based on reason, of • Natural law • Legal Positivism • Two major representatives • John Locke (d. 1704) • Charles-Louis de Secondat, Baron de La Brède et de Montesquieu (d. 1755)

  13. Category III-xiiBasic Law of the Constitution-ii • Locke • The most influential figure on the Declaration of Independence • Thomas Jefferson-- the 3 greatest minds ever: • Isaac Newton • Francis Bacon • John Locke

  14. Category III-xiiiBasic Law of the Constitution-iii • Natural law as the foundation and guiding principle of a legal community • People have a right to establish this legal community • Legislative power as the center of the legal community • Subject to the laws of nature and reason • Law is positive legislation that the legislature makes for the common good • The legislature is the highest power in the commonwealth • It receives its “legitimization from the decision of the people as fixed in the constitution” • Grounded in one’s natural right to the protection of one’s property

  15. Category III-xivBasic Law of the Constitution-iv • Montesquieu • “Law is oriented to the idea of justice and must be judged by it” • Each community must decide what justice is according to the spirit of the community • Separation of powers

  16. Category III-xvBasic Law of the Constitution-v • Nine sorts of law according to their function with relation to the various things in life • Law of nature • Divine law • Ecclesiastic/Canon law • International law • General constitutional law • Particular constitutional law • Law of conquest • Civil law • Family law • The constitution keeps these laws separate

  17. Week 4 Unit 4 History of Law: Category III: Positive/Realist Law Based on Reason Constitution, Society, and Leadership

More Related