1 / 21

Assessing Plant DBP Performance Using the DBP-CPE

2004 RMSAWWA/RMWEA Annual Conference Grand Junction, Colorado. Assessing Plant DBP Performance Using the DBP-CPE. Warren J. Swanson, P.E. Schmueser gordon meyer, inc. Glenwood Springs Aspen Crested Butte Meeker . Thanks to the Project Team…. Alison Dugan, USEPA, Cincinnati

kaili
Download Presentation

Assessing Plant DBP Performance Using the DBP-CPE

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. 2004 RMSAWWA/RMWEA Annual Conference Grand Junction, Colorado Assessing Plant DBP PerformanceUsing the DBP-CPE Warren J. Swanson, P.E. Schmueser gordon meyer, inc. Glenwood Springs Aspen Crested ButteMeeker

  2. Thanks to the Project Team… • Alison Dugan, USEPA, Cincinnati • Total System Optimization program • Larry DeMers, Process Applications, Inc., Fort Collins • R. Scott Summers, CU Boulder

  3. This Presentation Will… • Increase awareness of EPA’s optimization efforts • Introduce DBP optimization tools being developed for states and utilities • Hopefully, encourage participation!

  4. Why Optimize? Improve Water Quality in Your Community! Increase Operations Efficiency! Why Not? BoostWorkplaceSatisfaction! EnsureRegulatoryCompliance!

  5. What is a CPE? • Comprehensive • Technical, managerial, financial • Performance • Measured against goals that EXCEED regs • Roots in optimized filter performance • Evaluation • What limits a systems performance? • What control strategies apply? • Can optimization alone achieve goals?

  6. CPE Contexts and Uses • 1) Stand-alone evaluation • By a water utility or its consultant • By a State primacy agency • 2) Part of a larger program • EPA-State area-wide optimization programs

  7. What is a DBP-CPE? • Extension of traditional CPE • Focus: Simultaneous Optimization of • Disinfection • Disinfection By-Products • By nature, it’s scope is system-wide: Raw Water Quality Distribution System WTP

  8. DBP-CPE Components

  9. Optimized DBP Goals (currently draft) • TTHMs and HAA5 • Locational Running Annual Average Basis • TTHMs: 75g/L; HAA5: 55 g/L • Total Organic Carbon (TOC) Removal • Exceed Enhanced Coag.Requirements by 10%

  10. Case Study: City of Winchester, USA •  4.5-mgd conventional plant • 10,000 customers • No Stage 1 DBP Rule compliance issues • Higher than desired DBPs • Stage 2 compliance not a sure bet

  11. KMnO4 River Source Reservoir Source Cl2 Cl2 10-1000 NTU 1.5-4.5 ppm TOC FLOC/ SED CLEAR WELL MEDIA FILTERS RM PACl KMnO4 River Source Dist. Sys. Process Flow Diagram

  12. One of the First Steps: Historical Distribution System DBP Data Analysis

  13. Historical TOC Removal Performance Should be Assessed…

  14. @ Plant Effluent Disinfection Achieved / Required After Pre-Cl2 Segment Historical CT Data Are Very Useful…

  15. Special Study: On-Site DBP Profile Pre-Cl2 Segment Plant Effluent Dist. Sys.

  16. Historical Cl2 Residual Profiling

  17. Special Study: EC Jar Test Consider Secondary Impacts: -> Turb. -> pH -> Sludge

  18. Distribution System Can Be Important Area for DBP Control • TANK ANALYSIS TOOLS • Tank turnover spreadsheet •  Reducing Water Age • Tank mixing spreadsheet •  Reducing Stratification & DBP Excursions • BOOSTER CHLORINATION • Adds to optimization potential

  19. Control Strategies Are a Key Outcome of a DBP-CPE

  20. DBP Capability Assessment Provides Key Information to the Utility… • Even with optimization, can a plant meet the goals? • More challenging question than for a microbial CPE • “DBP Capability Assessment Tool” (DBP-CAT) • Predictive spreadsheet program • Considers major control strategies • Currently being field-tested

  21. Wrap-up • USEPA currently developing DBP optimization tools for States and water utilities • These tools are being developed and field-tested around the country • Project team seeks interested utilities! For more information, contact: warrens@sgm-inc.com Schmueser gordon meyer, inc. Glenwood Springs Aspen Crested ButteMeeker

More Related