1 / 32

Disproportionality & Producing Better Outcomes June 14, 2013

Disproportionality & Producing Better Outcomes June 14, 2013. What is Disproportionate Minority Contact (DMC)? DMC is the over or under representation of youth of color in the juvenile justice system. DMC is one of the 4 core requirements of the

kylee-shaw
Download Presentation

Disproportionality & Producing Better Outcomes June 14, 2013

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Disproportionality & Producing Better Outcomes June 14, 2013

  2. What is Disproportionate Minority Contact (DMC)? DMC is the over or under representation of youth of color in the juvenile justice system. DMC is one of the 4 core requirements of the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act.

  3. What are the 4 Core Requirements? Deinstitutionalization of Status Offenders. Sight and Sound Separation Jail and Lockup Removal Disproportionate Minority Contact

  4. “Recent research … indicates that in nearly all instances, the best public safety outcomes coincide with the least restrictive interventions for youth…” NJJN (2012), The Truth About Consequences

  5. Low Level Offenders • Diversion is more effective than formal processing • Diversion is more cost effective Anthony Petrosina, “Formal System Processing of Juveniles: Effects on Delinquency.” Campbell Systematic Reviews, 2010:1 (January 29, 2010)

  6. Serious Offenders • Institutionalization increased the level of offending. • Longer stays do not decrease recidivism. • Most felony offenders will stop offending on their own. • Community-based supervision is as effective as incarceration Edward P. Mulvey, et al., “Trajectories of a Desistance and Continuity in Antisocial Behavior Following Court Adjudication Among Serious Adolescent Offenders, “Development & Psychopathology, Vol. 22, Issue 2 (2010).

  7. History of DMC 1988 - Congress mandated DMC in state plans. 1992 – Congress tied 25% of funding to DMC work. 2000 – MJJA gathered county DMC statistics. 2001 – DMC Coordinators in large counties in MO. 2002 – Congress changed “confinement” to “contact.” 2003 – MJJA published a report demonstrating DMC in detention. 2004 –OSCA published Racial and Gender Equity Study. 2006 – Research project by MU. 2009 – Additional county DMC teams working.

  8. Missouri Facts 37 (out of 114 counties and 1 city) had some disproportionality at the referral decision point in 2011.

  9. What is the Relative Rate Index (RRI)? RRI compares rate of youth of color to rate of white youth at particular decision point

  10. RRI Calculation Example # of Black youth referred60 = .30 # of Black in population 200 ______________________________ (÷) # of White youth referred40= .05 # of White youth in pop. 800 .30= 6 RRI .05 Black youth are 6 times more likely to be referred.

  11. Missouri RRI 2011 for Status and Law Violations Court Contact Point AA Hisp. Asian Referrals 2.1 0.5 0.3 Diverted 0.9 0.9 * Secure Detention 1.5 1.7 * Charges Filed 1.6 1.4 * Delinquent 0.9 * * Probation 0.9 * * Confinement DYS * * * Certification 3.0 * * *Not statistically significant 1.0 = Proportionality

  12. RRI Ranges for Individual Counties for Law and Status Violations in 2011 Court Contact Point Ranges Referral 1.5 - 10.0 Diverted 0.7 - 1.2 (<1 is not good) Detention 0.7 - 4.0 Charged 0.7 – 3.0 Delinquent 0.9 Probation 0.7 (<1 is not good) Confinement 1.5 - 2.6

  13. Commonalities in Disproportionality Most disproportionality occurs at the referral decision point, and is with African Americans. 2. The majority of referrals are from law enforcement (this includes School Resource Officers).

  14. Commonalities in Disproportionality The Offenses with the most disproportionality are Assault 3rd Degree and Peace Disturbance.

  15. Commonality in Disproportionality • More disproportionality occurs with five or more referrals

  16. DMC Action Network Model for DMC Reduction

  17. Diverse Governing Body for DMC Reduction

  18. Effective Strategies • School Agreements • Mentoring Kids for At Risk • Law Enforcement Training • Teen Court in Schools

  19. Memphis, TNSchool House Adjustment Program Enterprise • Alternative to school referral for minor offenses • Written agreement • Parental consent • Restorative justice, behavior modification, etc. • Reduced DMC

  20. Memphis, TN School House Adjustment Program Enterprise John T. Hall, Memphis City Schools Coordinator, Department of School Security2597 Avery Avenue, Room 145 Memphis, Tennessee 38112Email:hallj@mcsk12.net,901-416-6259http://www.mcsk12.net/shape/

  21. Birmingham, AL • 1st offense: Warning/Written citation. Child and parent are informed about what happens with 2nd offense • 2nd offense: Child & parent attend School Offense Workshop. Both informed about what happens with the 3rd offense • 3rd Offense: Referral to Juvenile Court

  22. Birmingham, AL Presiding Judge Brian Huff, Jefferson County Family Court, 205-325-5538 huffb@jccal.org

  23. Atlanta, GA • 1st offense: Warning notice • 2nd offense: Referral to School Conflict Diversion Program • 3rd offense: Referral to Juvenile Office

  24. Atlanta, GA Steven Teske, Clayton County Juvenile Judge 9163 Tara BoulevardJonesboro, GA  30236Main Number: (770) 477-3270

  25. State System Progress • New statewide protocol for distinguishing the race and ethnicity of court-involved youth • New school resource officer (SRO) code for the statewide data system • New certification codes will be released soon to do a better job of tracking these cases

  26. Carolyn Kampeter, MO Juvenile Justice Association 573-636-6101 carolyn@mjja.org Christine Patterson, OSCA 573-751-4377 christine.patterson@courts.mo.gov

More Related