E N D
1. Promoting Health, Creating Hope IMPACT OF PATHOLOGY ON SAFETY AND ABILITY TO EXERCISE FOR PEOPLE WITH MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS
Brian Hutchinson, PT
President, The Heuga Center
2. MS Classifications
Relapsing-Remitting
Primary Progressive
Secondary Progressive
Progressive-Relapsing Generally, MS is separated into 4 classifications. Some people add a 5th category known as Benign MS so you may see that term. Relapsing Remitting is the most commonly seen type of MS in which the disease course consists of exacerbations and remissions. Primary progressive MS is less common. Primary progressive MS is characterized by a fairly rapid increase in disability but does not consist of relapses. Secondary progressive MS is generally characterized by individuals who initially have a relapsing remitting course but then demonstrate a progressive course but not necessarily a rapid increase in disability. Finally, Progressive-Relapsing is characterized by an steady increase in disability with occasional exacerbations.Generally, MS is separated into 4 classifications. Some people add a 5th category known as Benign MS so you may see that term. Relapsing Remitting is the most commonly seen type of MS in which the disease course consists of exacerbations and remissions. Primary progressive MS is less common. Primary progressive MS is characterized by a fairly rapid increase in disability but does not consist of relapses. Secondary progressive MS is generally characterized by individuals who initially have a relapsing remitting course but then demonstrate a progressive course but not necessarily a rapid increase in disability. Finally, Progressive-Relapsing is characterized by an steady increase in disability with occasional exacerbations.
3. MS Demographics Onset most commonly between ages 20 and 40
Affects women about twice as often as men
Greater incidence in northern climates (above 40th parallel)
Greater incidence in individual of Northern European descent
Statistics courtesy of the National MS Society MS is most commonly diagnosed between the ages of 20-40 and the majority of people are diagnosed with relapsing-remitting MS. MS affects women about twice as often as men. There is a greater incidence in northern climates and is more common in individuals of Northern European descent.MS is most commonly diagnosed between the ages of 20-40 and the majority of people are diagnosed with relapsing-remitting MS. MS affects women about twice as often as men. There is a greater incidence in northern climates and is more common in individuals of Northern European descent.
4. Pathophysiology Blood brain barrier breakdown
Autoimmune/inflammatory response
Myelin damage
Lesion formation
Axonal damage and atrophy The pathology of MS involves a number of factors including a breakdown of the blood brain barrier, an autoimmune/inflammatory response, myelin damage, lesion formation and axonal damage and atrophy.The pathology of MS involves a number of factors including a breakdown of the blood brain barrier, an autoimmune/inflammatory response, myelin damage, lesion formation and axonal damage and atrophy.
5. Autoimmune Disorder Immune Response
Trigger
Blood brain barrier
Inflammatory process
Myelin damage
Lesion formation
Axonal damage and atrophy Current Immunomodulating
Interferon beta 1a
Interferon beta 1b
Glatiramer Acetate
Mitoxanthrone
Plasmaphoresis
MS is an autoimmune disorder. The immune response is triggered, most likely by a virus or combination of viruses, this in turn causes a breakdown of the blood brain barrier. This leads to an inflammatory response and demyelination. The damaged area forms a scar or sclerosis. In addition, to damaging the myelin it is now known that there is axonal damage and in turn atrophy. The axonal damage originally was thought to occur after years of damage to the myelin. Now it has been shown to occur early and late in the disease process.
Current treatment includes immunomodulating treatments. The treatments approved for relapsing MS have been shown to slow the progression of the disease and decrease the number of exacerbations. Mitoxanthrone and Plasmaphoresis have been primarily used for progressive forms of MS to slow the progression of the disease. MS is an autoimmune disorder. The immune response is triggered, most likely by a virus or combination of viruses, this in turn causes a breakdown of the blood brain barrier. This leads to an inflammatory response and demyelination. The damaged area forms a scar or sclerosis. In addition, to damaging the myelin it is now known that there is axonal damage and in turn atrophy. The axonal damage originally was thought to occur after years of damage to the myelin. Now it has been shown to occur early and late in the disease process.
Current treatment includes immunomodulating treatments. The treatments approved for relapsing MS have been shown to slow the progression of the disease and decrease the number of exacerbations. Mitoxanthrone and Plasmaphoresis have been primarily used for progressive forms of MS to slow the progression of the disease.
6. Common Symptoms Fatigue
Weakness
Spasticity
Ataxia/Tremor
Parasthesias/Dysethesias
Dysarthria/Dysphagia
Bowel/Bladder/Sexual Function
Cognitive
Emotional
Visual These are some of the common symptoms people with MS may experience. Symptomatology is dependent upon the location and number of lesions. Symptoms vary in number and severity. Individuals with MS may not experience any of these symptoms and some may experience all of them.These are some of the common symptoms people with MS may experience. Symptomatology is dependent upon the location and number of lesions. Symptoms vary in number and severity. Individuals with MS may not experience any of these symptoms and some may experience all of them.
7. Symptom Management
Medications
Rehabilitation
Surgical In addition, to disease modifying agents, it is important to manage a persons symptoms. There are a number of different methods for symptom management but most fall into three main categories. Medications. There are a number of medications utilized to manage the symptoms mentioned earlier. Rehabilitation is very often used in symptom management; to lessen the effects of the symptoms or help one learn compensatory strategies to increase independence. Rehabilitation is also used to prevent occurrence of other symptoms and secondary complications. Finally, surgical intervention is sometimes required to manage symptoms. Primarily, secondary complications such as contractures (tendon releases), decubiti (flap repairs), spasticity (intrathecal baclofen) and tremors (deep brain stimulation)In addition, to disease modifying agents, it is important to manage a persons symptoms. There are a number of different methods for symptom management but most fall into three main categories. Medications. There are a number of medications utilized to manage the symptoms mentioned earlier. Rehabilitation is very often used in symptom management; to lessen the effects of the symptoms or help one learn compensatory strategies to increase independence. Rehabilitation is also used to prevent occurrence of other symptoms and secondary complications. Finally, surgical intervention is sometimes required to manage symptoms. Primarily, secondary complications such as contractures (tendon releases), decubiti (flap repairs), spasticity (intrathecal baclofen) and tremors (deep brain stimulation)
8. Effects of MS on Exercise
Primary
Secondary
Tertiary MS can affect exercise three different ways. Primary, Secondary and TertiaryMS can affect exercise three different ways. Primary, Secondary and Tertiary
9. Primary Effects of MS on Exercise Blunted Blood Pressure Responses
Dampened arterial blood pressure response to sustained isometric exercise (Pepin, et.al., 1996 & Ng, et. al., 2000)
-Pepin: Impaired autonomically mediated pressor response
-Ng: A function of dampened muscle metabolic response
May affect ability for one to attain target zone if an autonomically mediated response
Primary effects include a blunted heart rate response. Pepin in 1996 and Ng in 2000 demonstrated a dampened arterial blood pressure response to sustained isometric exercise. However, they differed on the mechanism for the response. Dr. Pepin felt that the dampened response was due to an impaired autonomically mediated pressor response while Dr. Ng felt it was a muscle metabolic response. If this is an autonomically mediated response, it could certainly affect heart rate, of a person with MS, and affect their ability to attain a target heart ratePrimary effects include a blunted heart rate response. Pepin in 1996 and Ng in 2000 demonstrated a dampened arterial blood pressure response to sustained isometric exercise. However, they differed on the mechanism for the response. Dr. Pepin felt that the dampened response was due to an impaired autonomically mediated pressor response while Dr. Ng felt it was a muscle metabolic response. If this is an autonomically mediated response, it could certainly affect heart rate, of a person with MS, and affect their ability to attain a target heart rate
10. Primary Effects of MS on Exercise
Fatigue
Central
Peripheral
Thermosensitivity
Other primary effects of MS includes fatigue. Approximately 85% of people with MS have complaints of fatigue. There is evidence of central fatigue, once again lending credence to dysautonomia and conduction block. In addition, there is the short-circuiting fatigue commonly seen with MS which leads to weakness. Finally, there is thermosensitivity in which nerve conduction is slowed with increased heat and this produces an increase in symptoms.Other primary effects of MS includes fatigue. Approximately 85% of people with MS have complaints of fatigue. There is evidence of central fatigue, once again lending credence to dysautonomia and conduction block. In addition, there is the short-circuiting fatigue commonly seen with MS which leads to weakness. Finally, there is thermosensitivity in which nerve conduction is slowed with increased heat and this produces an increase in symptoms.
11. Secondary Effects of MS on Exercise Impairments
ROM
Strength/Weakness
Sensation
Balance/Coordination
Fatigue due to Deconditioning
Pain
Medication Effects Secondary effects of MS on exercise include these impairments. Some of these impairments can be related to nerve conduction problems and therefore might be considered primary effects but as it relates to exercise they are generally more secondary effects. These impairments are often seen in people with MS and can certainly affect ones ability and motivation to exercise.Secondary effects of MS on exercise include these impairments. Some of these impairments can be related to nerve conduction problems and therefore might be considered primary effects but as it relates to exercise they are generally more secondary effects. These impairments are often seen in people with MS and can certainly affect ones ability and motivation to exercise.
12. Secondary Effects of MS on Exercise Disability
Mobility
-Difficulty achieving desired levels of exercise (unable to perform previous activities)
Cognitive
Additional secondary effects are those related to disability. The most common disability which effects ones ability to exercise are problems with mobility. Difficulties with mobility creates difficulty achieving desired levels of exercise. Many people feel they must exercise at the level or the exact same way they used to exercise and if they do not, then it just isnt exercise. Mobility disability can certainly force someone to look at different ways or different types of exercise.
Cognitive disability can also create difficulties in initiating or maintaining an exercise program. Additional secondary effects are those related to disability. The most common disability which effects ones ability to exercise are problems with mobility. Difficulties with mobility creates difficulty achieving desired levels of exercise. Many people feel they must exercise at the level or the exact same way they used to exercise and if they do not, then it just isnt exercise. Mobility disability can certainly force someone to look at different ways or different types of exercise.
Cognitive disability can also create difficulties in initiating or maintaining an exercise program.
13. Tertiary Effects of MS on Exercise
Emotional
Decreased motivation
Family/community support
Coping skills
Accessibility
Equipment
Location(s)
Expertise Finally, there are the tertiary effects of MS on exercise. Emotional aspects can include decreased motivation, limited family and/or community support making exercise more difficult. Also, a persons coping skills can have an effect on his/her ability to exercise. As mentioned in the earlier example: if I cant do it the way I used to, then it doesnt pay to do it at all.
Accessibility can also be a barrier to exercise including equipment, location, and expertise of people who understand MS and can help direct and guide someone through their exercise program.Finally, there are the tertiary effects of MS on exercise. Emotional aspects can include decreased motivation, limited family and/or community support making exercise more difficult. Also, a persons coping skills can have an effect on his/her ability to exercise. As mentioned in the earlier example: if I cant do it the way I used to, then it doesnt pay to do it at all.
Accessibility can also be a barrier to exercise including equipment, location, and expertise of people who understand MS and can help direct and guide someone through their exercise program.
14. Effects of Exercise on People with MS Improvements in Impairments
Improvements in Disability
Improvements in Quality of Life
Improvements in Health Measures However, there are many benefits that exercise has on people with MS. First we can see improvements in impairments, disability, quality of life and health measures.However, there are many benefits that exercise has on people with MS. First we can see improvements in impairments, disability, quality of life and health measures.
15. Effects of Exercise on People with MS Improvements in Impairments
Improve range of motion
Improve strength
Improve endurance/decrease fatigue
Decrease pain However, exercise can help improve range of motion (Brar, 1991), strength (Chen, 1987; Gehlsen, 1984; Ponichtera-Mulcare, 1993;) endurance (Gehlsen, 1984; Petajan, 1996; Schapiro, 1988, Svennson, 1994) and pain.However, exercise can help improve range of motion (Brar, 1991), strength (Chen, 1987; Gehlsen, 1984; Ponichtera-Mulcare, 1993;) endurance (Gehlsen, 1984; Petajan, 1996; Schapiro, 1988, Svennson, 1994) and pain.
16. Effects of Exercise on People with MS Improvements in Disability
Improved mobility
-Improvement with bed mobility
-Improvement with transfers
-Improvement with ambulation
Improvement with activities of daily living (ADL)
In addition, prudent, well-rounded exercise can improve mobility including bed mobility, transfers and ambulation (Rodgers, 1999; Wiles, 2001). Also, it can include function with ADLs (Lexell, 2000)In addition, prudent, well-rounded exercise can improve mobility including bed mobility, transfers and ambulation (Rodgers, 1999; Wiles, 2001). Also, it can include function with ADLs (Lexell, 2000)
17. Effects of Exercise on People with MS Improvements in Quality of Life
Emotional behavior
Social interaction
Recreation
Home management
Reduction in depression
Reduction in anger
Improvements in quality of life include improved emotional behavior, social interaction, recreation and home management as measured on the Sickness Impact Profile. In addition, decreases in depression and anger as measured by the Profile of Mood States.(Petajan, 1996)Improvements in quality of life include improved emotional behavior, social interaction, recreation and home management as measured on the Sickness Impact Profile. In addition, decreases in depression and anger as measured by the Profile of Mood States.(Petajan, 1996)
18. Effects of Exercise on People with MS Improvements in Physical Health Measures
VO2 max
Percent body fat
Blood lipids
Finally, the improvements seen with physical health measures include increased VO2 max, decreased percent body fat and improvement in blood lipid levels. (Petajan, 1996)Finally, the improvements seen with physical health measures include increased VO2 max, decreased percent body fat and improvement in blood lipid levels. (Petajan, 1996)
19. Summary MS and accompanying symptoms can cause difficulty with exercise
The benefits of exercise outweigh the potential difficulties because of the benefits associated with reducing disability, improving quality of life and improving overall health So we have seen that MS and the accompanying symptoms can cause difficulty with exercise but we also have seen, and will discuss in further detail tomorrow, that the benefits of exercise outweigh the potential difficulties or barriers.So we have seen that MS and the accompanying symptoms can cause difficulty with exercise but we also have seen, and will discuss in further detail tomorrow, that the benefits of exercise outweigh the potential difficulties or barriers.
20. References Brar, et.al., Evaluation of Treatment Protocols on Minimal to Moderate Spasticity in Multiple Sclerosis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 1991; 72: 186-189
Chen, et.al, Force Time Measurements of Knee Muscle Fundtions of Subjects with Multiple Sclerosis. Phys. Ther, 1987; 67: 934-940
DeSouza, A Different Approach to Physiotherapy for Multiple Sclerosis Patients. Physiotherapy, 1984; 70: 429-432.
Freeman, et.al., The Impact of Inpatient Rehabilitation on Progressive Multiple Sclerosis. Ann Neurol, 1996; 39: 432-441
Freeman, et.al., Inpatient rehabilitation in multiple sclerosis. Neurol, 1999; 52: 50-56
Gehlsen, et.al, Effects of an Aquatic Fitness Program on the Muscular Strength and Endurance of Patients with Multiple Sclerosis. Phys Ther, 1984; 64: 653-657
Kidd, et.al., The benefit of inpatient neurorehabilitation in multiple sclerosis. Clin Rehabil, 1995; 9: 198-203.
Lexell, Muscle Structure and Function in Chronic Neurological Disorders: The Potential of Exercise to Improve Activities of Daily Living. Ex Sport Science Rev, 2000; 28: 80-84
21. References National Multiple Sclerosis Society website statistics
Ng, et.al., Blunted pressor and intramuscular metabolic responses to voluntary isometric exercise in multiple sclerosis. J Appl Physiol, 2000; 88: 871-880
Pepin, et.al., Pressor response to isometric exercise in patients with multiple sclerosis. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 1996; 28: 656-660
Petajan, et.al., Impact of Aerobic Training on Fitness and Quality of Life in Multiple Sclerosis. Ann Neurol, 1996; 39: 432-441
Ponichtera-Mulcare, Exercise and multiple sclerosis. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 1993; 25: 451-465
Rodgers, et.al., Gait characteristics of individiuals with multiple sclerosis before and after a 6-month aerobic training program. J Rehabil Res Dev, 1999: 36: 183-188
Schapiro, et.al., Role of Cardiovascular Fitness in Multiple Sclerosis: A Pilot Study. J Neuro Rehab, 1988; 2: 43-49
22. References Stephens, et.al., Use of Awareness Through Movement Improves Balance and Balance Confidence in People with Multiple Sclerosis: A Randomized Controlled Study. Neuro Rep, 2001; 25: 39-49
Solari, et.al., Physical rehabilitation has a positive effect on disability in multiple sclerosis patients. Neurol, 1999; 52: 57-62
Svensson, et.al., Endurance Training in Patients with Multiple Sclerosis: Five Case Studies. Phys Ther, 1994; 74: 1017-1026
Wiles, et.al., Physiotherapy Improves Mobility, Subjective Well-Being in Patients with MS. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2001; 70: 174-179