1 / 19

Value-Focused Process Engineering

Value-Focused Process Engineering. Porter & Millar [1985] – value chain Keeney [1992] – value-focused thinking Rossi et al. [2005] supply chain network a complex system SUPPLY CHAIN RISK MANAGEMENT : reducing supply chain vulnerability Identify and correct malfunctions & disruptions.

pfunk
Download Presentation

Value-Focused Process Engineering

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Value-Focused Process Engineering Porter & Millar [1985] – value chain Keeney [1992] – value-focused thinking Rossi et al. [2005] supply chain network a complex system SUPPLY CHAIN RISK MANAGEMENT: reducing supply chain vulnerability Identify and correct malfunctions & disruptions Finland 2010

  2. Supply Chain Risk Management Areas of vulnerability & risk (in supply chains) • Identification– Hallikas et al. [2002; 2004] • Recognize future uncertainties • Identify organizational exposure to uncertainty • Known, unknown, unknowable risks • Assessment • Analysis • Treatment Finland 2010

  3. Supply Chain Risk Identification Methodology • Value-Focused Process Engineering (Neiger et al. [2003; 2004, 2006]) • Neiger, D.; Churilov, L.; zur Muehlen, M.; Rosemann, M., Integrating risks in business process models with value focused process enginnering, Proceedings of the 2006 European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS2006), Goteborg, Sweden 12-14 June 2006 • Reduce level of uncertainty • Identify process-based risks • Holistic perspective • Supply chain a set of interconnected value-adding processes • Risk reduction expressed as business objectives • Process, Objectives, Risk Source Finland 2010

  4. Risk Identification • Use Organizational objectives to identify, assess risk • Treat risks as natural attributes of organizational value-adding mechanisms • Include risks as part of objectives structure • They claim not adequately implemented • Link risks to Supply Chain activities • Link risks to individual risk sources • Quantify risks • Fault tree analysis; Event tree analysis • Enable cross-organizational risk visibility • They claim not adequately implemented • Decompose risk by process flow Finland 2010

  5. Value-Focused Process Engineering • Systems methodology • Holistic representation of business • Value-Focused Thinking (Keeney 1992) • Link business processes, objectives • Fundamental objectives – hierarchy of business purposes • Means objectives – methods to achieve ends • Extended Event-driven Process Chain process modeling methodology (Scheer 1999) • Intuitive graphical business process description in terms of business logic • VFPE ties objectives & processes Finland 2010

  6. VFPENeiger & Churilov [2004] • Company values • Hierarchy of fundamental objectives • What do you mean by that? • DECISION MAKER VALUES • 1st Level means objectives(how can you achieve?) • What objectives, activities aim to accomplish this? • VALUE ADDED CHAIN • Means of Achieving • Network of means objectives • What objectives, activities aim to accomplish this? • HIERARCHY OF DECOMPOSED PROCESSES Finland 2010

  7. Risk Identification Process • Activity driven identification or risk objectives • Objective driven identification of risk objectives • Synchronized decomposition • E-EPC taxonomy of risk sources • Joining events structure to objectives structure Finland 2010

  8. Example Finland 2010

  9. Example • 1. Activity-based risk identification • Each high level functional objective separated into risk, performance-based objectives • Put risk in context of other performance dimensions • 2. Objectives-driven risk identification • Min risk of supplier non-conformance • Min poor supplier collaboration • Min supplier financial instability • Min nonstandard workflow • Min dependence on supplier • Min risk of supplier becoming competitor Finland 2010

  10. Tie each decomposed function to objectives in 2. • 3. Synchronized decomposition • Choose contracting out method • Choose basis for contract reimbursement • Define supplier selection criteria • Involve authorized suppliers • Involve external suppliers • Weight selection criteria • Send Request for Proposal • Provide quote • Evaluate offers Finland 2010

  11. 4. Apply e-EPC taxonomy of risk sources Finland 2010

  12. 5. Join Events to Objectives • Paper emphasized identification aspect • Another methodology of thinking of all possible things that can go wrong • Good • Systems view • Consideration of organizational objectives • Supply chain view (interorganizational) Finland 2010

  13. Value Hierarchy for Supply Chain Risk Finland 2010

  14. MAUT Plant Siting – group 1 Finland 2010

  15. MAUT Plant Siting – group 2 Finland 2010

  16. Value Scores – group 1 Finland 2010

  17. Value Scores – group 2 Finland 2010

  18. Weight Development1- rank order Finland 2010

  19. Value Ranking Finland 2010

More Related