1 / 21

International Diplomacy

International Diplomacy. International College Khon Kaen University Week 2 – The Role of Diplomacy - Power and Diplomacy. The Role of Diplomacy. We have looked briefly at why governments need to consult together (international relations), and

pier
Download Presentation

International Diplomacy

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. International Diplomacy International College KhonKaen University Week 2 – The Role of Diplomacy - Power and Diplomacy

  2. The Role of Diplomacy • We have looked briefly at why governments need to consult together (international relations), and • We noted that governments develop foreign policies – strategies to enhance their security, welfare and prestige • This week we focus on diplomacy’s role in foreign policy implementation

  3. The Role of Diplomacy • Foreign policy-making has two separate stages: • The policy-making decisions on what a country’s foreign policy should be • The implementation of that policy (the how) • The policy-making process is largely a political one, agreed at a party (political) level to appeal to voters and to secure the political fortunes of the party in power

  4. The Role of Diplomacy • The implementation process is very often non-political; it is largely the responsibility of officials • But the “what” and the “how” stages cannot be separated easily • The policy-making and the policy implementation are parts of a continuous and interactive process

  5. The Role of Diplomacy • The four main functions of diplomats (see Week 1 notes) all contain elements of policy-making and of implementation • Diplomacy as a government activity is mainly concerned with foreign policy implementation

  6. The Role of Diplomacy • Diplomats are normally officials who work closely with senior government ministers of their home country (in socialist countries directly with the party in power) • But government leaders – Ministers and government politicians - are also diplomats when abroad and representing the foreign policy interests of their government

  7. The Role of Diplomacy • Every government has a specialized agency devoted to foreign policy • This usually takes the form of a Ministry (or Department) of Foreign Affairs linked to a network of embassies and consulates abroad • The Ministry and all its diplomatic missions overseas are often referred to as the diplomatic machinery of government

  8. The Role of Diplomacy • This diplomatic machinery represents an important policy instrument in its own right • Communication and negotiation (“pure diplomacy”) is sometimes sufficient to achieve some or all of a state’s foreign policy objectives • Most often however diplomacy is linked to other policy tools (“mixed diplomacy”)

  9. The Role of Diplomacy • In mixed diplomacy the use, or threatened use, of other tools becomes a factor in implementing foreign policy • These other tools of foreign policy include: • trade and economic sanctions • travel restrictions (another from of sanction) • international shame • Diplomacy usually has comparative advantages over other tools in terms of availability, cost and reputation

  10. The Role of Diplomacy • Smaller states and developing countries are handicapped as effective international actors by having smaller and less well trained diplomatic machinery • They also have a more restricted range of supporting policy tools • They can partly overcome these weaknesses by working together with other countries with similar interests

  11. The Role of Diplomacy • This explains the growing importance of regionalism and internationalism in international diplomacy • Bilateral diplomacy is increasingly being supplemented by regional and multilateral forms of diplomacy • Globalization and interdependence are challenging traditional state-to-state diplomacy (and the importance of nation states in international relations)

  12. Power and diplomacy • States use diplomacy as their first choice in implementing foreign policy • Pure diplomacy is easier, cheaper and more honorable than mixed diplomacy • But even pure diplomacy is almost never a process of communication and negotiation between equals • Every state has its own set of strengths and weaknesses which influence the nature and the timing of diplomatic exchanges

  13. Power and diplomacy • It makes little difference if a diplomatic negotiation is about cooperation, competition or confrontation – the relative power of the states involved influences the negotiation • Power is an important element of diplomacy • National power is the sum of a country’s assets that enhance its ability to get its way • But measuring power is difficult

  14. Power and diplomacy • Some aspects of power (military strength, economic strength) can be measured • Other aspects of power (military morale, security of the government, intelligence) are almost impossible to measure

  15. Power and diplomacy • Some of the major measurable aspects of a country’s power: • Its geography (location, terrain, size, climate) • Its people (population, education levels, age) • Its government (stability and legitimacy) • Its military strength and spending • Its national economy (GDP, resources, industrial output, agricultural output) • Its infrastructure (communications, transport, technology, R&D capabilities)

  16. Power and diplomacy

  17. Power and diplomacy • All these aspects of power serve as a backdrop to diplomatic negotiations • The importance of different aspects of power varies according to the subject under negotiation: • In free trade talks, the size of a country’s economy, market and resources are most important • In negotiations on nuclear proliferation, countries with access to nuclear fuels and technology will be the major participants

  18. Power and diplomacy • The relative power of two or more countries in a negotiation will also determine its diplomatic stance: • Smaller, weaker countries will seek to cooperate with other countries and will often be more willing to compromise • A large and powerful country will have less interest in compromise or in seeking consensus

  19. Power and diplomacy • Although diplomacy is heavily influenced by power considerations, the post-Cold War era is notable for an increasingly rights-based, internationalist approach • Since the early 1980s there has been a greater emphasis on what is right, fair and “in everyone’s interest”: • development considerations • equity issues • human rights issues • environmental issues • freedom from nuclear threats

  20. Power and diplomacy • Greed and naked self-interest win few friends internationally – and every country needs friends • The “soft power” of pure diplomacy is displacing the “hard power” of mixed diplomacy on many issues • This trend is supported by the increasing body of international law and rules-based international organizations – all countries are subject (in theory at least) to the same laws and rules

  21. Power and diplomacy • Failure to abide by these laws and rules can lead to international censure, isolation and/or retaliatory action

More Related