580 likes | 706 Views
Examples of the CAVE working for Scientists. Rachael Brady Beckman Institute, UIUC August 15, 2000. Outline. Crumbs Overview Motivation Rendering Toolset Audio Formative Evaluation Uses by Scientists. Writing a VR Application for Scientists (Biologists). Navigation
E N D
Examples of the CAVE working for Scientists Rachael Brady Beckman Institute, UIUC August 15, 2000 CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Outline • Crumbs Overview • Motivation • Rendering • Toolset • Audio • Formative Evaluation • Uses by Scientists CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Writing a VR Application for Scientists (Biologists) • Navigation • Driving/Flying paradigms only work with landmarks and horizon • Interaction • Object control • Parameter setting • Measuring • Hardcopy CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Illustration or Exploration • Illustration • High rendering quality • Annotation • Accurate measurements • Exploration • Fast, interactive rendering • Multiple viewpoints • Multiple viewing tools • Measurement/Analytic tools CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
48 Hour Old Chicken Embryo Jo Ann Eurell, Janet Sinn-Hanlon Veterinary Biosciences, UIUC Exploration Illustration CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Crumbs General viewing tool for regularly gridded 3D scalar data in the CAVE. Developed to trace and measure 1D fibers CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Outline • Crumbs Overview • Motivation • Rendering • Toolset • Audio • Formative Evaluation • Uses by Scientists CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Motivation of Crumbs (Feb ’94) • Problem • Trace and model fibrous structures in dense, volumetric datasets from imaging modalities such as MRI, TEM and Optical Microscopy • Will a virtual environment help? CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Ray Traced Texture Mapped Volume Rendering CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
First Attempts • Navigation • Flying • Outside/Inside + Map • Windshield • Physical Object you pick up & resize • Rendering • Show entire data set at once • Viewing window • Several viewing windows • Slices CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Current Features • Parameter Settings • Menus • Colormap & Opacity Control • Voice Command • Crumbs Placement • Intelligent use of space • Spline Plane • Sonification CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
What Crumbs Looks Like in Use Data volume is a horse fetlock (ankle). Source: Mark Martinelli CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Outline • Crumbs Overview • Motivation • Rendering • Toolset • Audio • Formative Evaluation • Uses by Scientists CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Crumbs Environment CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Color Map Adjustment CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Opacity Adjustment CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Voice Command Necessary for Instrument Control CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
crumbs Manipulation CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Spline Plane CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Outline • Crumbs Overview • Motivation • Rendering • Toolset • Audio • Formative Evaluation • Uses by Scientists CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Audio • Ambient Sounds (mood music) • Event Feedback • Localization • Sonification • Can sound help in Crumbs placement? • Must be fatigue resistant • Must convey data value • Must synchronize with graphical rendering & task Music CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
First Attempt • Four Melodies • Orchestration mapped to data value • Implemented by Robin Bargar & Insook Choi CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Current Implementation • No MIDI device needed • Implementation by Carlos Ricci CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Current Implementation CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Outline • Crumbs Overview • Motivation • Rendering • Toolset • Audio • Formative Evaluation • Uses by Scientists CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Formative Evaluation • Kent Swartz & Deborah Hix • Virginia Tech, Dept. of Computer Science • Umesh Thakkar • University of IL, NCSA CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Formative Evaluation - Tasks • Crumbs has “feature-itis”. Decided to focus on core task of placing crumbs along a 1D feature of interest. • Two data sets chosen. • Fertilized fruit fly embryo, place crumbs along sperm tail within egg nucleus • Human Spine, place crumbs on 3D centroid of each vertebrae CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Formative Evaluation - Users • User #1, pilot study • Wide VR experience, demos Crumbs, not user • User #2 • Wide VR experience, runs Crumbs for demos, used once for own data • User #3 • User, no VR experience • User #4 • Developer, no VR experience • User #5 • User, no VR experience CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Formative Evaluation - Survey Results CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Formative Evaluation - Results • Removal of objects from the environment • Delete vs. Hide, not a problem in general. One person had trouble with this. • Some aural feedback choices “bad” • “Ouch” caused people to release button and cringe • “Good Luck” made people pause and wonder why • “Grab and Drag” button changes for thumbslider on Opacity, Colormap & Contrast tools • True problem. Lots of confusion from this • Suggestion: Grey out unavailable options on the menu CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Outline • Crumbs Overview • Motivation • Rendering • Toolset • Audio • Formative Evaluation • Uses by Scientists CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Uses by Scientists • Fruit Fly Fertilization • Protozoa • Spinal Stenosis • Human Pharynx • Egyptian Mummy • Chicken Development • Oil Exploration • Plasma Physics • Optical Tomography • Architecture CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Drosophila Sperm Tails Tim Karr University of Chicago Beckman Institute UIUC CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Structure of fertilized Drosophilla Egg CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Evolution of sperm study • What is length of tail? 1994 - 1995 • Initially used CAVE to trace twisting, knotty tail in order to determine length. Topological accuracy was not important. CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Evolution of sperm study • What is shape of tail? 1996-1998 • Why do different species have different shapes? • What is statistical variation of shape within a species? CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Evolution of sperm study • How does sample preparation effect measurements (1999-present) • Results so far: • Same prep, same gestation, same species yield measurement repeatability within 5% • Compression of sample from confocal imaging results in longer tail measurements CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Sperm’s effect on Crumbs • Added capability to view many tracings simultaneously • Added seim-automatic tracing capability • Branching capability out of knots Published in Nature (1995) and Science (1996) CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Oral Region Infundibulum Peristome Trochal Band Aboral Region Howard E. Buhse Jr. Biological Sciences University of Illinois at Chicago Protozoa: Vorticella convallaria CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Structure of Vorticella convallaria CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Discovering the OF-1 Antibody in the Myonemes • Use of the confocal microscope forced the scientist to prepare his organism with a different stain • The proteins carrying the stain appeared in an unexpected location in the organism CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Spinal Stenosis Budinger, Schoenem, Maltz, LBL CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Spinal Stenosis • Want to find point of tightest constriction along vertebrae of spine • Added capability to select locations for 2D slices, and save images to disk • Results: no significant differences discovered from classical methods CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Human Pharynx David Kuehn & Sandy Ettema Speech and Hearing Science, UIUC CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Mummy Sarah Wisseman Ancient Technologies UIUC CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Mummy • CAT scan performed at CARLE clinic • Mummy is boy, around 9 years old • Teeth • Pelvis • Body is on wood (pine?) board • Organs not removed prior to mummification CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
48 Hour Old Chicken Embryo Jo Ann Eurell Janet Sinn-Hanlon Veterinary Biosciences, UIUC CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Chicken Embryo • Optical serial sections • 24-hour and 48-hour embryos available • Used as field trip for developmental biology course • Heart development • Nervous system development • Now illustration available (video) CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Oil Exploration • Seismic data is very dense and difficult to see structures • Slice planes most popular rendering method • Incorporated ability to render predefined meshes so that land marks could be seen in seismic volume • Jan 99: oil drill hit calcium deposit • decided to stop drilling in that location • used Crumbs to explore area around well • data showed oil deposit behind deposit • continued drilling: found deposit worth $15M CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series
Militzer/Ceperly version of Crumbs Path-integral Monte Carlo simulations of hydrogen. The calculation is used to study hydrogen transition from the plasma state with free protons and electrons to a molecular gas, and finally to molecular metallic liquid. CAVERNUS - Advanced CAVE Workshop Series