260 likes | 271 Views
Explore the concept of nullifying unjust laws and whether individuals have the right to refuse to follow them. Discuss the methods of peaceful resistance and forceful defiance, examining the Reform Era, Temperance Movement, Education Reform, and Women's Suffrage. Analyze the effectiveness of pre-Civil War Temperance Movement and the struggles faced by women in gaining their rights.
E N D
Jump Start • If a law is passed that you consider unjust, do you have the right to nullify/not follow it? • Why or why not? • In your opinion, how should you go about defying (not following) the law? Peacefully or with force? And why? • I NEED AT LEAST HALF A PAGE OF WRITING!
Reform Era: Temperance, Education, Women’s Suffrage, Prisons and Care for the Mentally Ill, Abolitionism
A Spirit of Revival • Second Great Awakening: 1790’s-early 1800’s • Revival of religious feeling • Differed from the 1st by introducing the idea that everyone could be forgiven for their sin • Doing good deeds could help you gain salvation • Helped jump start reform movement • Americans believed they could act to make things better • Transcendentalism: the belief that the spiritual world is more important than the physical • People can find truth within themselves through feelings and intuition • Thoreau was a pivotal figure • Civil Disobedience: urged people to peacefully refuse laws they considered unjust
Temperance Movement • Organized because consumption of alcohol significantly increased & caused social problems • Goal was to encourage moderation in the consumption of alcohol • Some groups pressed for complete abstinence • Heavy drinking led to many social problems • Movement was led by churches and religious groups • Propaganda focused on the sufferings of innocent mothers and their children
Temperance Unions • Groups that pushed for total prohibition • Considered drinking to be morally wrong • Believed it should be prohibited by law • Their demands led to experiments with more strict laws • The Civil War stalled the movement • Temperance was later revisited during the 1890’s-1920’s Woman's Christian Temperance Union (1874)
Annual Consumption of Alcohol 1720-1930 Use the graph to answer the following question. Also, you must provide evidence to prove your answer: How effective was the pre-Civil War Temperance Movement?
Education Reform • Early Schools • Short-term schools from the colonial era • 10-12 weeks per year • Provided basic instruction • Charged a fee along with community funding • Preferred teaching white boys • Schooling was costly and religiously based • was designed for the privileged • Parents were considered the primary educators • Families relied on each other and churches for additional learning
Horace Mann and “Common Schools” • Reformers argued that INFORMED CITIZENS were needed for our republican GOVERNMENT TO THRIVE • Workers wanted their children to have a chance to pursue the “American dream” • Horace Mann promoted PUBLIC SCHOOLS as the only way to EQUALIZE SOCIETY • He argued that it was impossible that educated people could remain permanently poor • Mann worked for many reforms in public education: • Paid for and run by the public • Inclusive of children from different backgrounds • Taught by well-trained professional teachers
Early Public Schools • Despite reformers efforts, public school conditions were poor: • Lacked funding, books, and equipment • Teachers were poorly paid and often poorly prepared • Kids that went beyond the elementary grades went to private academies • Public schools did not become well established until after the Civil War 1800’s Georgia school house
Women’s Rights • The Industrial Revolution changed the economy • People separated from homes • Home became a refuge • Different roles (jobs) for men and women • STATUS of women remained similar to what it had been during the colonial era • Could not go to college, vote or hold most professional jobs • Had no control over their children or property • Needed husband’s permission to make a will, sign a contract, or file a lawsuit • BUT they were able to work out of the home
Organizing the Movement • Many northern women were involved in the Abolitionist Movement • Their involvement in suffrage reform increased after the World Anti-Slavery Convention of 1840 • Women were excluded from speaking at the convention and were forced to listen from behind a curtain • Two female reformers, Lucretia Mott and Elizabeth Cady Stanton, decided it was time to stand up for women’s rights • They planned to hold their own convention when they returned home Admission ticket to the Convention
Seneca Falls Convention and Declaration • The women wrote a document modeled after the Declaration of Independence • It went over a list of complaints and ended with a demand for rights • The movement was ridiculed and the demand for suffrage remained until 1920 • BUT women did gain more rights when it came to property and wages “. . . The history of mankind is a history of repeated injuries and usurpations on the part of man toward woman, having in direct object the establishment of an absolute tyranny over her. . . . He has never permitted her to exercise her inalienable right to the elective franchise. He has compelled her to submit to laws, in the formation of which she has no voice. . .” Elizabeth Cady Stanton, The Declaration of Sentiments The first signatures on the Declaration of Sentiments.
Legacy of the Movement • Seneca Falls helped create an organized campaign for women’s rights • Reformers made slow progress • New York gave women control over property and wages • Massachusetts and Indiana passed more liberal divorce laws • Some women began their own businesses • However, women’s suffrage took decades • 19th Amendment passed in 1920 • Only one woman present at the convention lived to vote
Prison Reform • During the late 1700’s to early 1800’s the general belief about human nature was that people were generally good and capable of improvement • This new belief was a big shift from the earlier Puritan belief of humans as naturally sinful • This idea brought many changes for prisoners and the disabled OR
From Prison to Penitentiary • Colonial prisons were used as holding places before punishments or as places for debtors • Reformers argued that society would benefit more from rehabilitating prisoners than punishing them • Would also help our economy because prisons could double as workshops for profit • By 1850, most states had adopted the penitentiary system • Penitentiary: prisons used for housing prisoners as punishment and rehabilitation
Prisons and the Mentally Ill • Before the 1800’s, the mentally ill were kept at home or imprisoned • By 1815, asylums appeared that separated the mentally ill from prisoners • Dorothea Dix led the reform movement for the mentally ill • Boston school teacher who was asked to teach Sunday school at the East Cambridge House of Correction in 1841 • Found a room full of mentally ill women neglected and left without heat during the New England winter Tranquilizing Chair
Dorothea Dix and Reform “the present state of insane persons confined within the Commonwealth, in cages, closets, cellars, stalls, pens! Chained naked beaten with rods, and lashed into obedience!” • After her experience, Dix spent two years investigating jails and asylums in Massachusetts • Keepers of the institutions called her charges “slanderous lies” but she won the support of leading reformers • 20 states adopted laws to improve conditions • 32 new hospitals were built due to her efforts
OR ?
Abolitionist Movement • By the 1830’s people began asking “how can America, ‘the land of the free’, stillallow slavery” • Some people opposed it even before the American Revolution • Quakers • The Atlantic Slave trade was outlawed in 1808 BUT the Industrial Revolution and the invention of the cotton gin made both the North and the South dependent on slavery • Abolitionists were people who wanted to end slavery regardless of this economic dependence • Both whites and African Americans were abolitionists
Famous Abolitionists • Although the North profited from plantation systems and slavery, some white Northerners joined the Abolitionist Movement • William Lloyd Garrison: began to publish an abolitionist newspaper, The Liberator • Even more rare were Southern abolitionists • Grimke Sisters (Sarah and Angelina): Grew up on a plantation but believed slavery was morally wrong • Moved north and joined the movement • Spoke out against slavery publically even at a time when women were not supposed to speak in public
Famous Abolitionists • Some abolitionists wanted to do more than just campaign for laws • Some brave abolitionists helped slaves escape to freedom • Harriet Tubman- one of the most famous conductors on the Underground Railroad • an above ground series of escape routes from the South to the North • Travel by foot, wagon, boats, and trains • Traveled by night and hid all day in “stations” • Tubman was also an escaped slave • Made 19 dangerous journeys to free enslaved people • Slave owners offered $40,000 for her capture, but she was never captured, nor did she lose a “passenger”
Famous Abolitionists • Some escaped slaves also joined the movement and spoke from their past experiences • Frederick Douglass:became a lecturer for the Mass. Anti-Slavery Society • People who heard him considered him to be too educated and well-spoken to have ever been a slave • We wrote an autobiography that was an instant best-seller • Started his own newspaper North Star • Waged a strong campaign against slavery • Sojourner Truth: fled her owners and lived with Quakers who set her free • Drew huge crowds throughout the North as she spoke for abolition • Both were able to change the way Northerners viewed slavery • BUT slavery continued for another 30 years
Important People & Achievements in the Temperance Movement • Some of the most notable figures associated with the U.S. temperance movement were Susan B. Anthony, Frances E. Willard and Carry A. Nation • The effects of their efforts included: • Government regulation • Instruction on alcoholism in schools • Energized study of alcoholism • 18th Amendment (1919-1933) which led to Prohibition: (ban on manufacture, consumption, distribution & sale of alcohol)
Inside Look: Carrie A. Nation (1846-1911) • In 1880, Kansas residents had voted for prohibition, but the law was largely ignored by saloonkeepers. • Saloons operated openly, but Nation would change all that. • First she prayed in front of an establishment in 1890. • She struck at her first saloon on June 1, 1900. • Initially, she used rocks, bricks and other objects for these attacks, then turned to the hatchet. "I felt invincible. My strength was that of a giant. God was certainly standing by me. I smashed five saloons with rocks before I ever took a hatchet." – Carrie Nation
Propaganda: Then and Now • Your goal is to examine pieces of propaganda from both eras to determine the message being sent. For each piece you need to answer the following questions: • Is this piece an example of temperance propaganda or current day propaganda? How do you know? • What is the main idea of the piece? • How does the artist use the people and objects to create the main idea? • How does the artist use emotion to accomplish their goal? What emotions does this piece make you feel?