340 likes | 420 Views
Social Finance for Social Innovation in Wood Buffalo. PRESENTED BY Sean Geobey PhD Candidate, McConnell Fellow. Introductions Tell us about yourself! Name Organization/affiliation What you do Interest in this workshop. WHAT WE WILL SPEND OUR DAY DOING…. Agenda. What is a Stakeholder?.
E N D
Social Finance for Social Innovation in Wood Buffalo PRESENTED BY Sean Geobey PhD Candidate, McConnell Fellow
Introductions Tell us about yourself! • Name • Organization/affiliation • What you do • Interest in this workshop
What is a Stakeholder? • Person, group, organization, member or system impacted by program
Exercise • We are going to take a high-level perspective on the question ‘Who are the key stakeholders (organizations, groups of people) that your program impacts?’. • On small sticky notes identify the stakeholders you interact with. For example, you could consider: • Public agencies • Companies or other market forces • Who would be impacted if you were not there • Our goal is to clarify the strategic context that you are working within
Financial Stakeholders • What do resource-providers expect to gain? • What is risky about providing support? • Example: Bad press, seen as “waste”, etc. • Common themes
Social Finance Tools • Impact Investing • Community Bonds • Social Impact Bonds • Crowd Finance
Finance Production Consumption + Interest Savings
What is Social Finance? • Finance with a social and/or environmental mission +
Legal Forms • For-profit • Non-profit • Non-profit with charitable status
Access to Capital • Equity (stocks) • Debt (loans) • Grants (donations +) • Revenue (sales of goods & services)
Social Finance • [Investments] made into companies, organizations and funds with the intention to generate measurable social and environmental impact alongside a financial return (Global Impact Investment Network 2012) • $4.5 billion in Canada (Bragg 2010) • Comparison: • Canadian assets under management is approximately $3 trillion (source Mobilizing Private Capital for Public Good 2010) • Total credit union / caissespopulaires assets $304 billion (Credit Union Central 2011; Desjardins 2010) • Donations to charity total $10.6 billion (Turcotte 2012)
Upcoming Activity • Each group will have a topic • Microfinance • Community Bonds • Social Impact Bonds • Crowd Funding • Teach the rest of the workshop • When would this type of financing make sense? • When would this type of financing not make sense? • Where would it be useful in Wood Buffalo?
Microfinance • Small loans • 2006 Nobel Peace Prize • MuhammedYunus & Grameen Bank • Supports self-employment activities • Profitable in developing world • Coupled with other assistance in Canada
Example: PARO Centre For Women’s Enterprise • Northern Ontario • Up to $5,000 loans • Multistage microfinance projects • Business coaching and mentorship
Community Bonds • Debt funding to organization • Can be asset-backed • Price accessible to community • Market or below-market interest • Issued by bank or credit union
Example: Centre for Social Innovation • Centre for Social Innovation (Toronto) • Funding new building • CSI had a city-backed loan guarantee
Social Impact Bonds • Not a bond • Government pay-for-performance • Private financing • Handoff from philanthropy to public funding • Focus on scaling proven interventions • “Bet” between finance and government http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E6GrQtCh83w
Example: Peterborough (UK) • 2010 UK pilot – Peterborough Prison recidivism • Case management oriented • If reoffending drops 7.5% then payout is 7.5% • If more can increase up to 13.5% • If 7.5% not achieved, no payout • SIB is not finished yet
Crowdsourcing • Raising small amount from many people • Online, usually donations • Often other benefits if repaid • Access to events • Early release of products • Loans and equity are difficult
Example: Pebble Watch • Customizable wristwatch • Electronic watch faces • University of Waterloo / Palo Alto, CA • $100,000 goal • $10,266,845 raised • Pledges of $99+ will receive a Pebble watch • Largest Kickstarter campaign to date
Activity • Discuss in your group • When would this type of financing make sense? • When would this type of financing not make sense? • Where would it be useful in Wood Buffalo? • Present findings to the rest of the workshop
Social Return On Investment • Social Return On Investment (SROI) Principles • Involve stakeholders • Understand what changes • Value what matters • Materiality • Avoid over-claiming • Transparency • Verification
Theory of Change • How do you impact stakeholders? • How do they view risk? • What does reporting impact mean to them? Program System
SROI Process • Establish Scope & Identify Stakeholders • Map Outcomes • Evidence Outcomes and Value • Establish Impact • Calculate SROI • Report, Use and Embed
1. Establish Scope and Identify Stakeholders Use big post-its to identify 2-5 key stakeholders Stakeholder (eg. member) Program (eg. bikeshare) Stakeholder (eg. transit) Stakeholder (etc.)
2. Map Outcomes & 3. Evidence and Value Outcomes Use small post-its to identify inputs & outcomes Intervention (eg. bikeshare) Stakeholder (eg. member) Outputs (note) Shared bikes & bike stands Kilometers travelled? Inputs Membership fees Personal biking gear Outcomes (value) Increased transportation range Reduced transportation costs
4. Establish Impact &5. Calculate SROI Outcomes (With proxy valuation) Deadweight (what would’ve happened anyway) Displacement (what moved elsewhere) Attribution (how much is this activity responsible for) Drop-off (how long does the effect last) Calculate SROI (Share attributable to program)
6. Report, Use and Embed • Stakeholders and SROI • Verification • Use • Can your stakeholders benefit from reporting? • How? • Think about your strategic goals • Can reporting improve and embed your strategy?
Activity: Your Social Return On Investment • In your group • Describe your program • Describe your stakeholders • Explain how the inputs and outcomes work • In pairs • Interview each other for 5 minutes each • How could your report to your stakeholders • Explain your partner’s reporting strategy to group
Using Social Finance • Which (if any) social finance tools could you use? • Are there opportunities for revenue generation? • Go through each project individually • Impact investing • Community bonds • Social impact bonds • Crowd financing • Which tool did your group find most useful? • Share with whole workshop
Wrap-Up • Write down • Most important thing I learned • An idea I can implement • Within your group • Go around the circle and share your answers • Are there any common themes? • Share the themes with the whole workshop
Questions? Sean Geobey PhD Candidate, Environment and Resource Studies McConnell Fellow SiG@Waterloo sgeobey@uwaterloo.ca