1 / 8

Informal meeting of EU Water Directors

This document discusses the use of exemptions mechanisms under Article 4.7 of the EU Water Framework Directive. It explores the conditions, criteria, and key issues related to granting exemptions for new modifications to water bodies. The document also addresses the need for guidance and support from stakeholders and member states.

valeriee
Download Presentation

Informal meeting of EU Water Directors

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Informal meeting of EU Water Directors Discussion document on article 4.7 London 28-29 November 2005 Gilles Crosnier Gilles.crosnier@cec.eu.int European Commission, DG Environment Unit D.2 – Water and Marine, WFD Team

  2. Why this document ? • Logical follow-up of the paper on environmental objectives endorsed by the Water Directors in June 2005 • Strong demands from many stakeholders and some MS for developing guidance on the use of exemptions mechanisms • Specific interests for “new modifications” exemptions mechanisms

  3. 4§7 allows failure to achieve environmental objectives when it is the result of: New modifications to the physical characteristics of a SWB or alterations to the level of GWB New sustainable human development activities Typical examples: new facilities for hydropower, navigation, flood defence, water abstraction or the settling of new industries in “high status” areas. Purpose of article 4.7

  4. Use of article 4.7 – 4 Overall conditions • 1) Assessing if the new modifications will lead to a failure in achieving the environmental objectives of a given WB • 2) Passing a successful test for 4 technical and socio-economical criteria • 3) Checking if that derogation does not compromise the achievement of the environmental objectives in other WB within the same RBD and is consistent with other EU environmental legislation (art 4§8) • 4) Ensuring that at least the same level of protection due to existing Community legislation is guaranteed (art 4§9)

  5. Use of article 4.7- 4 criteria • 1) Overriding public interest and/or better environmental/ health/safety options • 2) No possible alternatives (technical feasibility or disproportionate costs) • 3) take all the practicable mitigation measures • 4) Embedment in the RB management plan

  6. Some key issues • Links with SEA & EIA Directives • Notion of overriding public interest • Possible alternatives • Mitigation • Side-effects of the derogation (e.g. links with Natura 2000) • Content of the RB management plans

  7. Open questions to the Water Directors • Should this initiative cover only article 4§7 or all exemptions cases? • Support and/or assistance to develop papers with the EC and the interested stakeholders? (proposition: use of the environmental objectives paper drafting group)

  8. Other point for information • EC has committed itself for a cost-benefit assessment of WFD implementation by 2006 with the assistance of the MS • A specific study will be launched in 2006. MS will be requested for support in term of available reports or studies.

More Related