1.09k likes | 1.38k Views
Why Do Teens Sleep Too Little? Biology and Society . Mary A. Carskadon, PhD Sleep for Science Research Lab EP Bradley Hospital Alpert Medical School of Brown University Providence, RI. Overview. Examine adolescent sleep behavior Review developmental changes of sleep-wake regulation
E N D
Why Do Teens Sleep Too Little? Biology and Society Mary A. Carskadon, PhD Sleep for Science Research Lab EP Bradley Hospital Alpert Medical School of Brown University Providence, RI
Overview • Examine adolescent sleep behavior • Review developmental changes of sleep-wake regulation • Identify other factors that constrain teen sleep • Introduce some behavioral challenges of insufficient sleep
Adolescent Sleep Behavior • Bedtime becomes later • Rise time becomes earlier (school dependent) • Total amount of sleep is reduced
Adolescent Sleep Behavior 8.3 7.6 6.6 5.4 National Sleep Foundation, Sleep in America Poll, 2006
Adolescent Sleep Behavior 8.3 7.6 6.6 5.4 National Sleep Foundation, Sleep in America Poll, 2006
Adolescent Sleep Behavior National Sleep Foundation, Sleep in America Poll, 2006
Adolescent Sleep Behavior National Sleep Foundation, Sleep in America Poll, 2006
Adolescent Sleep Behavior 2242 2312 0000 0054 National Sleep Foundation, Sleep in America Poll, 2006 Yang et al., Pediatrics, 2005 (Korean Teens)
Adolescent Sleep Behavior 0718 0700 0648 0618 National Sleep Foundation, Sleep in America Poll, 2006 Yang et al., Pediatrics, 2005 (Korean Teens)
Adolescent Sleep Behavior 8.3 7.6 6.6 5.4 National Sleep Foundation, Sleep in America Poll, 2006 Yang et al., Pediatrics, 2005 (Korean Teens)
How much sleep do adolescents need? • Converging evidence indicates that optimal sleep for the average adolescent may be 9+ hours • National Sleep Foundation borderline sleep = 8-9 hours
Discrepancy Adolescent sleep need, therefore, does not appear to parallel sleep obtained for many teens.
Factors that Underlie the Discrepancy • Developmental changes in sleep regulation • Circadian timing system • Sleep wake homeostasis • Developmental changes in psychosocial context • Parents and schools
Two-Process Model of Sleep Regulation (Borbély, 1982) • Process C: Circadian Rhythm • Process S: Sleep/Wake Homeostasis (sleep pressure) Borbély & Achermann, 2000
What developmental changes occur to the circadian timing system?
Circadian Regulation Changes: Measures to Assess Process C • Phase preference—when do you prefer to be active, sleeping, etc?
Circadian Regulation Changes: Measures to Assess Process C • Phase preference—when do you prefer to be active, sleeping, etc? • Phase of circadian rhythms—what time is it in your brain?
Circadian Regulation Changes: Measures to Assess Process C • Phase preference—when do you prefer to be active, sleeping, etc? • Phase of circadian rhythms—what time is it in your brain? • Period of the circadian timing system—what is the internal day length?
Circadian Regulation Changes: Measures to Assess Process C • Phase preference—when do you prefer to be active, sleeping, etc? • Phase of circadian rhythms—what time is it in your brain? • Period of the circadian timing system—what is the internal day length? • Phase response to light—does light work the same across adolescence?
Animals with Adolescent Phase Delay • Homo sapiens (humans) • Macca mulatta (Rhesus monkeys) • Octodon degus (degu) [some ?] • Rattus norvegicus (laboratory rat) • Mus musculus (laboratory mouse) • Psammomys obesus (fat sand rat) Hagenauer et al., Devel Neurosci, 2009
Phase Delay in Adolescent Humans • Chronotype • Circadian phase
Chronotype and Adolescence • European sample • Time of midsleep on “free” days • Delay is marked across the 2nd decade • Is the inflection a “biological marker for the end of adolesence?” Roenneberg et al., Current Biol., 2004
Melatonin Onset (DLMO) Phase and Puberty Stage Carskadon et al. NYAS, 2004
What might cause phase delay? • Changes in light exposure • Staying up later // more late light • Waking up later // less morning light
What might cause phase delay? • Changes in light exposure • Staying up later // more late light • Waking up later // less morning light • Change in phase-dependent sensitivity to light exposure
What might cause phase delay? • Changes in light exposure • Staying up later // more late light • Waking up later // less morning light • Change in phase-dependent sensitivity to light exposure • Lengthening of intrinsic circadian period (i.e., longer internal day length)
Exaggerated phase delay to light in pubertal female mice Hagenauer et al., Devel Neurosci, 2001; after Weinert & Kompaeurova, Zoology, 1998
Intrinsic Circadian Period: Adolescents vs. Adults Carskadon & Acebo Sleep, 2005
Circadian Rhythms Summary • Phase delays during adolescence • Phase preference is later • Melatonin phase is later
Circadian Rhythms Summary • Phase delays during adolescence • Phase preference is later • Melatonin phase is later • Phase-dependent light sensitivity may change
Circadian Rhythms Summary • Phase delays during adolescence • Phase preference is later • Melatonin phase is later • Phase-dependent light sensitivity may change • Intrinsic period may lengthen
Circadian Rhythms Summary • Phase delays during adolescence • Phase preference is later • Melatonin phase is later • Phase-dependent light sensitivity may change • Intrinsic period may lengthen • Result: Late nights are favored (so, too, late mornings)
What developmental changes occur to the sleep-wake homeostasis (sleep pressure) system?
The “look” of sleep changes Tarokh & Carskadon, Encyclopedia of Neuroscience, 2009
Measures of Process S • Slow wave (NREM stages 3+4) sleep [qualitative: Deep sleep]
Measures of Process S • Slow wave (NREM stages 3+4) sleep [qualitative: Deep sleep] • Slow-wave activity (SWA) in sleep [quantitative: Slow EEG waves]
Measures of Process S • Slow wave (NREM stages 3+4) sleep [qualitative: Deep sleep] • Slow-wave activity (SWA) in sleep [quantitative: Slow EEG waves] • Sleep propensity (speed of falling asleep)
Changes of Slow Wave Sleep and Slow Wave Activity (SWA) Jenni & Carskadon, Sleep, 2004
Changes of Slow Wave Sleep and Slow Wave Activity (SWA) Jenni & Carskadon, Sleep, 2004
Changes of Slow Wave Sleep and Slow Wave Activity (SWA) Jenni & Carskadon, Sleep, 2004
7.7 h 3.0 h 13.5 h 2.9 h Across pubertal development, SWA accumulation rate changes Tanner Stages 1/2 Tanner Stage 5 Jenni, Achermann & Carskadon Sleep, 2005
7.7 h 3.0 h 13.5 h 2.9 h td = 2.8 h Decay Time Constant td = 2.7 h Across pubertal development, SWA accumulation rate changes Tanner Stages 1/2 Tanner Stage 5 Jenni, Achermann & Carskadon Sleep, 2005
7.7 h 3.0 h 13.5 h 2.9 h td = 2.8 h Decay Time Constant td = 2.7 h ti = 8.9 h Rise Time Constant ti = 12.1 h Across pubertal development, SWA accumulation rate changes Tanner Stages 1/2 Tanner Stage 5 Jenni, Achermann & Carskadon Sleep, 2005
Model of Process S in Development Jenni & LeBourgeois Curr Op Psychiatry, 2006
Response to extended wakefulness during pubertal development 2.5 6.5 10.5 14.5 18.5 22.5 26.5 Hours Awake Taylor et al., J Sleep Res, 2005
Response to extended wakefulness during pubertal development 2.5 6.5 10.5 14.5 18.5 22.5 26.5 Hours Awake Taylor et al., J Sleep Res, 2005