Bedingungsloses Grundeinkommen in ganz Europa!

1. Europäische BürgerInnen-Initiative Grundeinkommen. Ergebnis – Analyse – Zukunftsperspektiven (7. Mai 2014) Bedingungsloses Grundeinkommen in ganz Europa!

2. Das BGE ist ein Geldbetrag, der bedingungslos von Geburt bis zum Lebensende an alle Menschen personenbezogen ausgezahlt wird. Dieser Betrag muss hoch genug sein, um ein zwar bescheidenes aber selbstbestimmtes Leben in Würde führen zu können. Er muss die Möglichkeit bieten, an der Gesellschaft teilzunehmen und sie mitzugestalten. Das BGE ersetzt nicht den Sozialstaat sondern transformiert das Sozialsystem von einem kompensatorischen zu einem emanzipatorischen.

3. Ziele der BürgerInnen-Initiative • Die Europäische BürgerInnen-Initiative “Bedingungsloses Grundeinkommen“ hatte „die Erforschung eines Weges zu emanzipatorischen sozialstaatlichen Rahmenbedingungen in der EU zum Ziel. • Langfristig geht es darum, allen Menschen in der EU die Befriedigung ihrer materiellen Bedürfnisse zur Führung eines würdevollen Lebens gemäß den Vorgaben der EU-Verträge als bedingungsloses individuelles Recht zu garantieren und ihre gesellschaftliche Teilnahme durch die Einführung eines Bedingungslosen Grundeinkommen zu stärken.“

4. Ergebnis • Pressemitteilung Runder Tisch – Grundeinkommen (Austria): • Wien, 09.01.2014 • Aufwärtstrend im Endspurt für ein Grundeinkommen • Nur noch wenige Tage für die EU-BürgerInnen-Initiative Bedingungsloses Grundeinkommen, um doch noch die Million zu knacken. Die Anzahl der Unterschriften wächst so schnell wie noch nie.

5. Ergebnis

6. Slowenien vor Kroatien und Belgien • Außerdem müssten vorgegebene Quoten in mindestens sieben Staaten überschritten werden. • Slowenien und Kroatien haben diese Vorgabe bereits erfüllt. • Als nächstes Land könnte Belgien die Marke überschreiten. Es fehlen nur noch etwa 2.000 Unterschriften. Dass das an einem einzigen Tag möglich wäre, zeigte gerade Bulgarien. An einem Tag wurden in Belgien immerhin über 300 Unterschriften gesammelt.

7. In absoluten Zahlen liegen erwartungsgemäß die bevölkerungsreichsten Länder voran: • Deutschland mit über 35.000 • vor Frankreich mit über 28.000 • und Spanien mit über 21.000

8. Ergebnis Stand an Unterschriften(% Angabe bezüglich des Quotums) 1. Bulgaria 237,1 % 2. Slovenia 154,3 % 3. Croatia 135,5 % 4. Belgium 115,2 % 5. Estonia 108,5 % 6. Netherlands 104,3 % 7. Hungary 88,0 % 8. France 67,4 % 9. Slovakia 65,2 % 10. Sweden 64,0 % 11. Spain 62,8 % 12. Austria 59,0 % (abgegeben 8.436, gültig 7.060) 13. Germany 54,6 % (abgegeben 41.886, gültig 37.799) TOTAL: 49,6 %

9. Obwohl das offizielle Ziel nicht erreicht wurde, gibt es viele Gründe, warum die Unterstützer eines gerechteren und einfacheren sozialen Sicherheitssystems zufrieden sind. • Sechs Länder - Bulgarien, Slowenien, Kroatien, Belgien, Niederlande und Estland erreichten ihre Unterschrifts-Quoten und ein Land, Ungarn, war nahe daran, seine Quote zu erreichen. • Die EBI ist nur der Anfang einer europäischen Bewegung in Richtung eines EU-weiten Bedingungslosen Grundeinkommens! • Neue Gruppen wurden in vielen Ländern gebildet, um diese Kampagne zu unterstützen, und die bestehenden BGE-Netzwerke wurden durch diese gestärkt.

10. Analyse • Der Ombudsman hat einen Fragenkatalog versendet, den die Organisatoren einer Europäischen BürgerInnen-Initiative (EBI) beantworten sollen, um daraus eine Analyse für Verbesserungen des Instrumentes „EBI“ einzuleiten. • Kurzfassung der 10 Fragen und Antworten aus der Sicht unserer Initative:

11. 1. Frage • Bekanntheit der EBI in der Öffentlichkeit? • The citizens´initiative is not sufficiently well known among the general public. To raise awareness the media have to report at least from time to time about this instrument and the current status of ECI´s in progress.

12. 2. Frage • Sind die Richtlinien der EU zur EBI ausreichend? • The information and guidance provided in the website is sufficient and in direct contacts the support was excellent: quick and clear, however sometimes disappointing, because no urgent proposed improvement of the regulation were “provisionally” supported, taking into account, that the final decision could be made after the validation procedure for the regulation in 2015.

13. 3. Frage • Benutzerfreundlichkeit der Software? • The actual filling in form is not user-friendly because there is to much information on the signing page which is not relevant to the singing. • An important point is that the signer does not have any response and proof of signing except the long number on the last page.

14. 4. Frage Ist die Verlängerung der deadline zum Sammeln der Unterschriften fair gestaltet worden? NO, this was not the case!!! Because almost all signatures are online signatures, it would be just fair and equitable, if the EU agrees that the one-year-running-time of any initiative should start only with the possibility to sign online. This could be applied also in a retroactive way concerning the running initiatives.

15. 5. Frage Ist das Unterzeichnen über „Papier-Formulare“ sinnvoll? It is necessary to have in addition to the online collection possibility, the possibility to collect signatures on paper forms. This is important, because not all persons have an internet access. The problem is, that the paper forms (and the online fields) are different in the Member States. The Annex III of the Regulation should be harmonized and simplified (all “hurdles” for collecting signatures, e.g asking for a passnumber) should be avoided.

16. 6. Frage Ist die Datensicherheit ausreichend? We have no problem concerning the treatment of personal data, because the “security against misuse” is very hight after the certification procedure. The problem is, that we have to destroy all data after the end of an ECI process. In an ongoing handling of the same topic, it would be very useful to have at least E-mail addresses of the persons, how have signed the ECI online. If this will be taken into account, also E-mail addresses are necessary and then the E-mail address could be used also as immediately answer, if a signature is accepted.

17. 7. Frage Anzeige während des Sammelprozesses über die Anzahl der Unterschriften? The possibility of tracking the number of signatures obtained throughout the collection period was implemented and it was very useful to see every day by everyone the numbers in each Member States. In our case we have asked the organizers in each Member State to give the number of signatures on paper forms per E-mail to the webmaster (Robin Ketelaar). The webmaster updated the statistic every day.

18. 8. Frage • Erfahrungen mit der Zusammenarbeit mit den „National Authorities“? • It should be made clear in the improved regulation 2015, that the task to come in contact with the “national authority” should be decentralized. Each organizer in a country has to get authorized (letter of attorney) by the organizer of the ECI, that she / he can act as “Organizer” with the “National Authority”, however from the “security management” point of view a centralized control should be secured (e.g. destroying the CDs and the paper forms). Only in cases, where Member States are not involved in a specific ECI, the “general organizer” should contact the national authority (if from those Member States also online signatures were received). • The contact with national authorities were in the most cases in a “friendly supporting atmosphere”. In our case the national authorities were not obliged to make the validation, but some have don it or are in progress to do it. • Very important for us was, that by postal service delay we received many paper forms after the end of our collection time (14th January 2014). So we have now in sum about 300.000 signatures (but not yet validated).

19. 9. und 10. Frage Welche Änderungen der EBI Regulierung werden vorgeschlagen? In our case we were very happy to get the offer from the EC for a hosing agreement and the possibility to use the host of the EC in Luxembourg free of costs. This offer should be given in future to all ECIs and should be mentioned as possibility in the improvement of the regulation 2015. The certification procedure was very time consuming, although we got very much support from the EC-team and the certification authority in Luxembourg. Therefore we would recommend the starting time of an ECI not be bound on the day of registration, bot on the day, on which all technical problems are solved, that online signatures are possible.

20. Fortsetzung Änderungsvorschläge • Annex III should be harmonized and the simplest rule • should be used for all • Member States. • FULL FIRST NAMES, FAMILY NAME, PERMANENT RESIDENCE • (street, number, code, city, country), DATE AND PLACE OF BIRTH, • NATIONALITY, DATE AND SIGNATURE (E-mail Address???)

21. Fortsetzung Änderungsvorschläge • The possibility to sign an ECI should be possible for all persons leaving in EU, independent of there Address, from where the signature will be performed.

22. Fortsetzung Änderungsvorschläge • In many cases the organizers have not enough “money background”. Everything have to be paid private and this is in many cases a very big disadvantage. • Therefore the improved regulation should give also financial support for all registered ECI.

23. Fortsetzung Änderungsvorschläge • One very important improvement would be, that the criteria for the registration of a proposed ECI should be changed, by deleting criteria (b): • Article 4 (2) • (b) the proposed citizens’ initiative does not manifestly fall • outside the framework of the Commission’s powers to submit • a proposal for a legal act of the Union for the purpose of • implementing the Treaties; • This Paragraph should be deleted or should include • beside the • …....for the purpose of implementing the Treaties; • …....for the purpose of amending the Treaties.

24. Zukunftsperspektiven • Das Ende der EBI ist der Anfang von UBIE • Um die aktuelle Dynamik zu nutzen, gehen die Bemühungen der AktivistInnen weiter, das Bedingungslose Grundeinkommen EU-weit zum Thema zu machen. • Das Ende der Europäischen Initiative soll gleichzeitig der Anfang einer neuen Organisation mit dem Namen Unconditional Basic Income Europe (UBIE) werden.

25. “Unconditional Basic Income” conference: • Emancipating European Welfare • (Brussels, 10. April 2014) • “Unconditional Basic Income Europe (UBIE)” Meeting • (Brussels, 11. and 12. April 2014)

26. Unconditional Basic Income: Emancipating European Welfare • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ktJyk_kj74A • Amana Ferro, European Anti Poverty Network: „Situation with income poverty and hidden poverty in Europe“ • Unterschiede und Gemeinsamkeiten, „but we all share the same goal“: „dignified income for all“, minimum income (focus of European Anti Poverty Network: 29 national members = national platforms, 18 European organisations such as Caritas, people in poverty as the true experts) and basic income; poverty = denial of human right, life free from wants and needs; höhere Löhne, wenn höhere soziale Sicherung (adequate income for everyone; income protection = ensures consumption, relaunching economy).

27. Ronald Blaschke, Netzwerk Grundeinkommen Germany: „Unconditional Basic Income – Consistently against (hidden) poverty and for real freedom for everyone“ • Unconditional basic income: effective against hidden poverty and for freedom for everyone; plus health care insurance or free health care • gets rid of stigmatisation, combats forced labor, gives everyone the freedom to choose what he/she wants to do, no economic dependency in work life, no economic dependency in family relations or partnerships

28. Elena Dalibot, European Alternatives, Citizens Manifesto for European Democracy, Solidarity and Equality – Different Needs and Solutions. • High unemployment rates, new situation ofworking poor, disengagement within and disappointment about EU of European citizens led to the idea that unconditional, universal, high basic income would maybe be a solution. • In face of crises, we are standing at a crossroad. This is an opportunity to show, that Europe could be at the avantguarde of a new experience, a new experiment. We should go for it. There is an urgency to act. We should be pushing for it on the ground and pushing decision makers.

29. David Casassas, Member of BIEN, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona: Democracy and Unconditional Basic Income • The unconditionality of basic income confers on individuals the relevant doses of bargaining power to say „no“, as a wider possible say, in order to say „yes“ to other yeses, to other social relations we wish to have today but we cannot develope because we must accept what is on offer out there. In effect, by guaranteeing our existence, the basic income plays a crucial role when it comes to autonomously decide how we want to live in the workplace, in the household and within political institutions.

30. Gerald Häfner, MEP, Greens: Development of ECI and EU-Referendum – tools for more democracy in the EU • All political groups in the parliament supported citizen-friendly ECI procedures. The commission and especially the council, the head of states – it is strange, that the heads of states play the most important role in the legislature - is completely against the idea of European democracy. I think that in all questions concerning Europe it needs to be the parliament or the citizens who have the last say in a decision and not the governments, this is wrong. • But the problem is, with the ECI, according to the Lissabon treaty, we can only invite the commission to take action. We cannot urge the commission. We cannot bind the commission. In my view, the ECI is only the first step in the direction of direct democracy.

31. What Häfner is organizing now is „democracy international“, a campaign for a new European convention. You need a convention to change the Lissabon treaty. Convention changes for more democracy but also for more solidarity, for many purposes. And we call for a European referendum at the end of this European convention process. „It is not their Europe. We are Europe, it is a Europe of the Citizens.“

32. Werner Rätz, Attac Germany, Working Group Enough for all and Working Group Beyond the Growth: Degrowth, Health and Unconditional Basic Income • The debate on an unconditional basic income is closely linked with the question of welfare in general. If you reflect upon this, a basic income obviously concerns people’s health, too. • But within the basic income movement there has been hardly a debate about this special idea. • Even less attention has been paid to the connection between basic income and degrowth.

33. A deliberately organised economic degrowth is required to prevent the social, economical disadvantages from losing the battle over the distribution of scarce ressources. • In this sense the unconditional basic income represents the basis to have the necessary debate in a fearless manner. • There is good proove that equality of income is much more important and has higher effect on peoples’ health than the quality of medical systems or individual health conscious behaviour.

34. Philippe Van Parijs, Chair of Advisory Board of BIEN: Euro- Dividend – An example for an partial basic income in Europe; • In order to move forward, we need two things at least: One is a vision, and the other one are opportunities.

35. Guy Standing, Honorary Co-President of BIEN: What can we learn from Namibian and Indian experiments with unconditional cash transfers? • I think we need to make sure all the time that we situate the debate, as we have been trying to do in the past 28 years, as • a question of emancipation, • a question of social justice and • a question of building a new distribution system • for the global economy.

36. Stanislas Jourdan, French Movement for UBI: How the ECI woke up the European movement • Valerija Korosec, UBI Slovenia: Running in the EU elections for UBI • Vahur Luhtsalu, UBI Estonia: Learning-by-doing: How we jumped on the ECI-UBI train (and what are the lessons learned) • Plamen Dimitrov, president of CITUB, Bulgarian Trade Union: Why Bulgarian trade unions are supporting UBI • Tomas Haimann, UBI Czech Republic: Perspectives from Eastern Countries • Anna-Béa Duparc, BIEN Switzerland: Lessons from the Swiss Federal Initiative for UBI and perspectives with the nationwide referendum • Lena Stark, UBI Sweden: UBI in the context of advanced welfare countries • Klaus Sambor, Runder Tisch Grundeinkommen Austria: The movement for UBI as part of wider social movements in Europe • Mihaela Meresi, Romanian Open Society Abroad (DP-ROSA): UBI as fundamental principle of political, economic and social redesign in Europe: building the Ethocratic Union • Samuel Pulido, UBI Spain, presentation on the Spanish Popular Initiative for UBI

37. “Unconditional Basic Income Europe (UBIE)” Meeting(Brussels, 11. and 12. April 2014) • 1) UBIE Charter • 2) UBIE Constitution • 3) UBIE Logo • 4) BIEN affiliation • 5) Creation of a new “Core Team” • 6) Aims and Activities for the coming year • 7) Next UBIE meetings • 8) Conclusion

38. UBIE Charter • We are an alliance promoting unconditional basic income • Art. 1 (Definition) • Unconditional Basic Income (UBI) is an amount of money, paid on a regular basis to each individual unconditionally and universally, high enough to ensure a material existence and participation in society. UBI is a step towards an emancipatory welfare system.

39. Art. 2 (Mission) • Our goals are: • - the introduction of unconditional basic income in Europe, • - its recognition as a Universal Human Right to live in dignity.

40. Art. 3 (Diversity) • We respect the diversity of views and opinions on Unconditional Basic Income. Different justifications and methods of implementation shall not prevent us from cooperating.

41. Art. 4 (exclusion from membership) • Racism in the sense of all forms of discrimination against people based on assumptions about group-specific characteristics is incompatible with membership and participation in the UBIE alliance.

42. Aims and Activities for the coming year • UBIE Website • Europäische BGE-Kampagne vor den Europa-Parlaments-Wahlen im Mai • EU-Pojekt: „Europe for Citizens programm“ • 7. Internationale Woche des Grundeinkommens • Photomontage / Videos / Filme • UBI und unterschiedliche Aspekte (z.B. UBI und Gesundheit) • UBIE-“Pamphlet“ • Crowd Funding • Teilnahme am BIEN Kongress in Montreal

43. Next UBIE meetings • Das 2. UBIE Meeting wird vom 27. - 28. Sept. 2014 in Athen stattfinden. • Das 3. UBIE Meeting wird im März 2015 in Slovenien (Ljubiana) stattfinden. • Conclusion • Der Übergang von der Europäischen “BürgerInnen Initiative zum BGE” zu dem nun offiziell gegründeten Verein “Unconditional Basic Income Europe (UBIE)” ist ohne Verlust der in der EBI aufgebauten Dynamik ausgezeichnet gelungen. Alle TeilnehmerInnen waren sehr zufrieden.