390 likes | 791 Views
Tamiflu ® (oseltamivir) Safety Update. Pediatric Advisory Committee Meeting November 16, 2006 Rosemary Johann-Liang, M.D., FAAP Deputy Director Andrew Mosholder, M.D., M.P.H. Epidemiologist Division of Drug Risk Evaluation FDA Center for Drug Evaluation and Research. Overview.
E N D
Tamiflu® (oseltamivir) Safety Update Pediatric Advisory Committee Meeting November 16, 2006 Rosemary Johann-Liang, M.D., FAAP Deputy Director Andrew Mosholder, M.D., M.P.H. Epidemiologist Division of Drug Risk Evaluation FDA Center for Drug Evaluation and Research
Overview • Background/Regulatory History • Brief Summary of 11/05 PAC • Safety Update • Drug Use Data • Skin/Hypersensitivity Reactions • Pediatric Death Reports • Neuropsychiatric Events
Background • Drug: Tamiflu® (oseltamivir phosphate) capsules and oral suspension • Therapeutic Class: Neuraminidase inhibitor • Sponsor: Roche Pharmaceuticals • Current Indications: • Treatment of influenza (≥ 1 yr) • Prophylaxis of influenza (≥ 1 yr)
PAC 11/05 Summary/Conclusions • FDA presentations of clinical trials safety data, pediatric post-marketing adverse event review, and literature review. • Presentations from CDC and Roche. • Unclear if neuropsychiatric AEs represent a safety signal associated with oseltamivir. • Pattern of neuropsychiatric AEs more suggestive of increased AE reporting from Japan, and disease manifestations of influenza. • Severe skin reactions less likely to be manifestation of influenza, more concern for drug-related AE.
PAC 11/05 Committee’s Charge • FDA is to return after 1 influenza season with a brief update to the PAC on any new developments in either adverse events or new information that may have developed within the next year. • In 2 years the PAC would expect a complete review of 2 influenza seasons and to have additional information from the sponsor from their U.S. United Health Care Claims Database and any other studies or databases to which they have access.
Update: Drug Use Data
Drug Use Data: Tamiflu® Source: Verispan Vector One® : National, MAT 2000-2006, data extracted 08-04-2006
Data courtesy of Hoffmann-La Roche, Inc. Japan : IMS Quarterly Rx Data until June 2005, Biannual data until June 2006 United States : IMS Weekly prescriptions until September 2006 Rest of World : IMS MIDAS Quarterly Retail data (Germany, France UK, Brazil, Canada, Argentina) until June 2006
Safety Update: Serious Skin and Hypersensitivity Reactions
AERS Update: Serious Skin and Hypersensitivity Reactions • December 19, 2005 postmarketing safety review identified 43 cases of serious skin reactions in FDA’s Adverse Event Reporting System (AERS), including 3 fatalities (all adults). • 16 of 43 were in pediatric patients • 24 cases of Stevens-Johnson Syndrome, 14 cases of erythema multiforme, 4 cases of toxic epidermal necrolysis, and 1 case of pemphigus • In addition to serious skin reactions, 75 other hypersensitivity reactions were identified from AERS and the literature. • This includes 6-anaphylactic reactions, 6-anaphylactoid reactions and 17-anaphylactic shock reports
Tamiflu®Labeling Update: 12/05 Precautions and Postmarketing sections of Tamiflu® (oseltamivir) Label updated December 21, 2005 • Precautions: Serious Skin/Hypersensitivy Reactions • “Rare cases of anaphylaxis and serious skin reactions including toxic epidermal necrolysis, Stevens-Johnson Syndrome, and erythema multiforme have been reported in postmarketing experience with Tamiflu. Tamiflu should be stopped and appropriate treatment instituted if an allergic-like reaction occurs or is suspected.” • Observed During Clinical Practice: Dermatologic: dermatitis, rash, eczema, urticaria, erythema multiforme, Stevens-Johnson Syndrome, and toxic epidermal necrolysis, (see Precautions)
Safety Update: Pediatric Death Reports
PAC 11/05: AERS Pediatric deaths • A total of 12 pediatric (<17 y/o) death reports in AERS as of Nov. 18, 2005 • Plus a 13th report of a 17 y/o boy • All reports from Japan • Co-morbidity and confounding factors in many of the cases. • Limited and missing data in majority of cases; difficult to assess cause of death. • Issues with translated reports and limited access to follow-up information make interpreting foreign reports challenging. • Based on available data, it is difficult to establish a direct relationship between the use of oseltamivir and the reported deaths.
Pediatric deaths reported with Tamiflu®: AERS update through 10/23/06 • Examined all pediatric AERS reports with fatal outcome irrespective of causality, age ≤17 y/o • 5 additional deaths reported since 11-18-05 • 2 US cases • 3 y/o healthy girl with flu with reported altered mental status. Diagnosis of “severe strep pneumonia” died due to sudden respiratory and cardiac arrest. • 8 y/o girl with history of SJS, TEN and anxiety after the use of oseltamivir and ibuprofen, needed prolonged and extensive rehabilitation, died 8-9 months after use of the drugs from unstated reasons.
Pediatric deaths reported with Tamiflu®: AERS update through 10/23/06 • 5 additional deaths reported since 11-18-05 • 3 Japanese cases • 7 y/o boy with Down’s Syndrome and flu. Difficulty breathing then sudden death (cardio-pulmonary arrest) with GI hemorrhage. • 3 y/o boy with influenza A and cardio-pulmonary arrest. Death possibly due to encephalopathy or cardiomyopathy. • 12 y/o boy with fever to 40 degree C, took 1 capsule of his brother’s Tamiflu and several hours later died in fall from high rise apartment building.
Pediatric deaths reported with Tamiflu®: AERS update through 10/23/06 • We noted that 3 out of 18 reported deaths in patients <17 y/o involved unusual traumatic injuries. • 14-year-old boy after 1 dose of Tamiflu fell off the 9th floor • 17-year-old boy after 1 dose of Tamiflu jumped over a concrete wall and leapt in front of a truck • 12-year-old boy after 1 dose of Tamiflu found in parking lot presumably due to a fall. • From available data, difficult to establish a direct relationship between the use of Tamiflu and the reported deaths; however, concerned about the pattern.
Safety Update: Neuropsychiatric Adverse Events
Safety Update: Neuropsychiatric events (Dec 2005 Review) • December 19, 2005 postmarketing safety review with supplement for prophylaxis indication identified 126 cases of neuropsychiatric events in AERS including 3 fatalities. • 17 of 126 categorized as cases of abnormal behavior including 2 deaths in Japanese patients < 18 yrs of age (14 and 17 yr olds) • Conclusions: not to label at this time, continue monitoring AEs for 2005-2006 influenza season, and reassess safety profile at end of the influenza season
Update: Postmarketing surveillance of oseltamivir neuropsychiatric events Purpose of this review: to update analysis of postmarketing reports of neuropsychiatric events with oseltamivir following the 2005-2006 influenza season
Update: Postmarketing surveillance of neuropsychiatric events • Methods • Search of FDA’s Adverse Event Reporting System (AERS) database • Reports received during time frame = 8-29-05 to 7-6-06 • MedDRA terms searched • HLT “Suicidal and Self-injurious Behaviour” • 30 additional preferred terms representing neuropsychiatric events • Suspect Drug = oseltamivir • Age = any • Case categories derived from manual review of reports
Results: Neuropsychiatric events • 129 AERS reports returned • 26 excluded • Narrative did not support • Medication errors • Confounded by concurrent medical or psychiatric disorders • 103 cases included in review • 95 from Japan, 5 from U.S., 3 from other countries • Median age = 12 yrs (range 1½ - 90) • Only 3 involved prophylactic use • 69 M, 32 F
Results: Categories and # of reports 1.Delirium with Prominent Behavioral Disturbances – 60 (US-1) 2. Suicidal events – 6 (US-1) 3. Panic Attack – 3 4. Delusions – 3 5. Convulsions – 12 (US-1) 6. Depressed Level of Consciousness – 6 7. Loss of Consciousness – 4 (US-1) 8. Miscellaneous – 9 (US-1)
Results: Fatal Cases 8/05-7/06 • Additional information received on 14 y/o boy found dead from 9-story fall after one dose, apparently had been hanging from balcony railing. • 44 y/o man received oseltamivir 75mg twice daily for influenza; 2 days later he committed suicide (fall); “open verdict” by coroner. • 51 y/o man hospitalized with tuberculosis; treated at 7 pm with one dose of oseltamivir for influenza A. Next morning committed suicide by jumping from hospital room; left suicide note.
Oseltamivir AERS reports of delirium with prominent behavioral disturbance, 8/05-7/06 • N = 60 • US: n=1 • 75% male • 17+ yrs: n=8 • 12-16 yrs n=14 • 6-11 yrs n=31 • 2-5 yrs n=7 • Median number of doses to onset = 1 • 1 dose n=38 • 1 or 2 doses n=52 • Dechallenge 35 pos, 6 neg • Reports confirming negative brain imaging studies (n=25) • Median fever = 39 deg C, n=11 with fever <38 • 1 report with prophylaxis
Oseltamivir AERS reports of delirium with prominent behavioral disturbance Examples • 11 y/o boy after two doses fell from landing, fractured skull and femur • 7 y/o boy 30 min post first dose ran from house screaming, later found at neighbor’s • 13 y/o, after one dose, apparently hallucinating and screaming about being chased, ran towards a 9th floor window • Literature report (Koide, 2006) of 8 y/o boy, ~90 min post first dose, agitated, growling, tried to run outdoors, memory impaired • 6 y/o boy got out of bed several hours after first dose, said a huge Pokemon told him to get up; minimal fever at the time
Additional Points on Neuropsychiatric Events Why so many reports from Japan? • Pediatric use >> than in U.S. • As yet unknown genetic risk factors could be more prevalent in Japanese population • More sensitive postmarketing surveillance system in Japan • Combination of all these factors
Additional Points on Neuropsychiatric Events • Influenza itself can be associated with delirium, and in some cases frank encephalitis • Relative contribution of drug versus viral illness difficult to define in the absence of systematic data • Degree to which oseltamivir crosses blood-brain barrier during acute illness unclear • Influenza is associated with serious morbidity and mortality • Drug risk evaluation always a balance of benefit/risk • Need for monitoring of patients emphasized
Additional Points on Neuropsychiatric Events • Characteristics of reports in this follow-up review make it uncertain that this is a disease-only process. • Temporality (1 – 2 doses to event) • “Drug –effect” as per reporting physician • Lack of negative sequelae after de-challenge • Absence of frank influenza encephalitis • Peculiar pattern (“abnormal behavior”) of adverse events, differs from the typical flu related CNS symptoms • Prudent to update the US labeling to be similar in scope to the current Japanese labeling. • Concern that if US drug use becomes similar to Japan use, there may be increasing AE consequences as well.
Labeling Recommendations: Neuropsychiatric events • Section under Precautions • Post-marketing reports (mostly from Japan) of self-injurious behavior and delirium with the use of Tamiflu. • Primarily among pediatric and adolescent patients with influenza • Relative contribution of the drug to these events is not known • Monitor for signs of abnormal (or unusual) behavior immediately after starting Tamiflu and throughout the duration of treatment. • If abnormal behavior, healthcare provider should be contacted immediately to determine appropriate treatment including whether Tamiflu should be discontinued.
Tamiflu® (oseltamivir) Safety Update : Summary/Plan • Labeling Updated • Serious Skin and Hypersensitivity Reactions • Drug utilization last year similar to previous several years • Updated review of pediatric AERS fatal reports with possible pattern of traumatic injury from “abnormal behavior” on drug • Follow-up neuropsychiatric AEs: cannot rule out drug – disease adverse effect. Predominantly in children and adolescents. • Labeling recommended on • neuropsychiatric events to be similar in scope to the Japanese current labeling • Need to closely monitor patient in order to prevent any attempt at unsafe behavior • Return next year for full report. 11/05 committee suggested that Roche report on studies which address this safety issue.
Acknowledgements • Evelyne T. Edwards, Pharm.D., M.A. • Melissa M. Truffa, R.Ph. • Jeff O’Neill, A.C.R.N. • Scott Proestel, M.D. • Vicky Borders-Hemphill, Pharm.D. • Hoffmann-La Roche, Inc.