320 likes | 648 Views
Tolvaptan for the Treatment of Hyponatremia. Cardiovascular and Renal Drugs Advisory Committee Meeting June 25, 2008. Aliza Thompson, MD Medical Officer. Tolvaptan’s Phase 3 Hyponatremia Trials. Study 156-03-238. Study 156-02-235. Washout. Washout. Tolvaptan Placebo.
E N D
Tolvaptan for the Treatment of Hyponatremia Cardiovascular and Renal Drugs Advisory Committee Meeting June 25, 2008 Aliza Thompson, MD Medical Officer
Tolvaptan’s Phase 3 Hyponatremia Trials Study 156-03-238 Study 156-02-235 Washout Washout Tolvaptan Placebo Serum Sodium (mEq/L) Time (Days)
Outline • Who was studied in tolvaptan’s development program? • Is serum sodium a valid surrogate for benefit in this population? • Did the development program establish tolvaptan’s safety in this population?
Who was targeted? Inclusion criteria • Hyponatremia (sodium < 135 mEq/L) in euvolemic or hypervolemic states Exclusion criteria • Acute and transient hyponatremia associated with head trauma or postoperative state • Sodium < 120 mEq/L with associated neurologic impairment (symptoms such as apathy, confusion, seizures, etc) • Likely to require IV saline for correction of symptomatic or asymptomatic severe hyponatremia during the course of the study.
Who was enrolled? Sodium (mEq/L)
Published literature: key considerations Are the findings generalizable to the population treated with tolvaptan? • level of serum sodium • acute vs. chronic hyponatremia • underlying etiology
The clinical significance of “mild” hyponatremia Hyponatremia and… • falls in the elderly • morbidity and mortality in heart failure patients • morbidity and health related quality of life in cirrhotics Is this association or is this causation?
Phase 3 Hyponatremia Studies: Secondary Endpoints 1. Average daily area under the curve of change in sodium up to Day 4, sodium < 130 mEq/L subgroup 2. Average daily area under the curve of change in sodium up to Day 30, sodium <130 mEq/L subgroup 3. Percentage of subjects with normalized sodium at Day 4 4. Percentage of subjects with normalized sodium at Day 30 5. Time to first normalization in sodium 6. Change from baseline in sodium at Day 4 7. Change from baseline in sodium at Day 30 8. Percentage of subjects requiring fluid restriction 9. Urine output at Day 1 10. Change from baseline in body weight at Day 1 for hypervolemic subjects. 11. Fluid balance at Day 1 for hypervolemic patients 12.Change from baseline in the SF-12 Physical Component Summary and Mental Component Summary Scales 13. Categorical change in sodium at Day 4 and Day 30, subgroup with sodium < 130 mEq/L 14. Categorical change in sodium at Day 4 and Day 30, subgroup with sodium ≥ 130 mEq/L 15. Percentage of subjects designated as treatment failures due to need for saline infusion
Phase 3 hyponatremia studies: Mental Component of the SF-12(Day 30) Trial 156-02-235 Trial 156-03-238
Phase 3 hyponatremia studies: Hyponatremia Disease Specific Survey • Developed internally by sponsor • Conducted in trial 156-03-238 at 3 time points during the course of the study • Following submission to NDA, exploratory analyses combined 4 questions to calculate a “mental component” • Difference in mental component score at Day 30 (estimated treatment effect -1.9 and -2.7 for subjects with a serum sodium < 135 and < 130 mEq/L respectively)
Phase 3 hyponatremia studies: Neurologic Examination • Included physician assessment of level of consciousness, ataxia, stance, gait, coordination*, muscle strength and tone, reflexes, dysarthria, tremor… • Depending on trial, measurements appear to be made 6 to 7 times during the course of the study • Differences between tolvaptan and placebo-treatment arms: • reflexes R and L achilles Week 1 in trial 156-02-235 • stance with eyes closed at Week 2 in trial 156-03-238 • ataxia at Day 37 in trial 156-03-238 (when subjects had been off drug for 7 days) *Limited data collected on stance, gait and coordination in trial 156-02-235
Worsening heart failure indication Tolvaptan-treated subjects in phase 3 heart failure trials (N=2063) Hyponatremia indication Tolvaptan-treated subjects in phase 3 hyponatremia trials (N=223) N=242 Subjects with hyponatremia due to SIADH/Other, Heart Failure or Cirrhosis Subset of heart failure subjects who also happened to have hyponatremia Tolvaptan’s development programs
Hyponatremic subjects in Phase 3 Heart Failure Trials • No difference in Kansas City Cardiomyopathy Questionnaire • Changes in body weight at day 1 and inpatient day 7 or discharge (< 1 kg difference between treatment arms) • Changes in patient-assessed dyspnea at Day 1
The data tell us about tolvaptan as a treatment for worsening heart failure. What do they tell us about the clinical benefits of treating a patient with tolvaptan to raise serum sodium?
The Safety Database (N=3294) Subjects with heart failure or hyponatremia Subjects with hyponatremia Phase 3 heart failure trials Other trials Phase 3 hyponatremia trials Subjects with hyponatremia
Subjects with hyponatremia (N=607) By Serum Sodium Level (mEq/L) By Underlying Etiology
Hyponatremia indication Tolvaptan-treated subjects in phase 3 hyponatremia trials (N=223) Hyponatremia due to SIADH/Other, Heart Failure or Cirrhosis Tolvaptan’s development programs Worsening heart failure indication Tolvaptan-treated subjects in phase 3 heart failure trials (N=2063) N=242 Subset of heart failure subjects who also happened to have hyponatremia
Mortality in the phase 3 heart failure studies Deaths on treatment or within 7 days of stopping (CI: 22.5, 26.3); Total N= 2055 (CI: 22.3, 25.9); Total N= 2063 (CI: 36.3, 49.1); Total N=232 (CI: 41.2, 53.8); Total N= 242
Phase 3 heart failure trials 242 40% The Safety Database (N=3294) Subjects with heart failure or hyponatremia Subjects with hyponatremia 2687 82% 142 607 Phase 2 trials 23% 18% 223 37% Phase 3 hyponatremia trials Subjects with hyponatremia
Adverse events in subjects with cirrhosis 1.8% (CI: 0, 5.3) 9.5% (CI: 2.3, 16.7) 9.5% (CI: 2.3, 16.7) 1.8% (CI: 0, 5.3) 17.5 % (CI: 8.1, 26.9) *Includes hematomas
Can the findings in tolvaptan’s development program be extrapolated to a population with more severe hyponatremia?
30 20 10 0 110 115 120 125 130 135 140 Efficacy in tolvaptan’s phase 3 hyponatremia trials Study 156-02-235 Study 156-03-238 Change in Sodium (mEq/L) Baseline Sodium (mEq/L)
Safety Subjects with hyponatremia: N=607 Serum Sodium Level (mEq/L) 137 130-134 23% 125-129 <125 52 9% 418 68%
Closing Comments • Who was studied in tolvaptan’s development program? • patients with mild and seemingly asymptomatic hyponatremia • Is serum sodium a valid surrogate for benefit in this population? • The clinical significance of raising serum sodium in this population remains unclear
Closing Comments • Did the development program establish tolvaptan’s safety in this population? • The database is limited, in particular with respect to subjects with SIADH, cirrhosis, and greater degrees of hyponatremia • In the setting of subtle or uncertain benefits, the tolerance for risk should be low
Closing Comments • Can we generalize these findings to a population with more severe hyponatremia?